360-degree feedback is the feedback a person receives from their manager, peers, team, and sometimes internal clients, in addition to their self-assessment. What determines its effectiveness is the questionnaire: questions about observable behaviors, a clear scale, and a few well-chosen open-ended questions.
This guide includes a ready-to-adapt question bank for each competency, the most commonly used rating scales, and rules for writing your own test items. If you're looking for information on how the entire process is organized, who participates, and how the report is submitted, visit the website of Hirint's 360-degree evaluation summarizes how it works in practice.
Table of Contents
What makes a 360 feedback question good?
A good 360 question describes something the person does that the evaluator has been able to observe. Bracken, Rose, and Church's review of 360 practice defines it precisely like this: evaluators are asked to state the degree to which specific behaviors occur, and it discourages items that require guessing what is going through the person's mind, with verbs like "understands" or "believes" (Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 2016).
The general rules for writing surveys also apply. The Pew Research Center recommends simple and concrete language, avoiding double negatives and technical jargon, and not asking about two things at once in the same question.Pew guide to survey questions).
Therefore, a 360 question should meet five conditions:
- Only one behavior per item. «"Communicate clearly and listen to your team" are two questions.
- Observable. Something that is seen or heard at work, not an intention or a trait.
- Specifically. «"Give specific recognition when someone does a good job" instead of "it's motivating.".
- Neutral. Without adjectives that push the answer ("always impeccable", "sometimes careless").
- Responsible for the recipient. If a peer can't see how to delegate, that question doesn't belong in their version.
| Not like that | That's more like it! |
|---|---|
| He is a good leader | Explain to your team why important decisions are made. |
| Understand the customer's needs | Ask the internal client what they need before proposing a solution |
| Communicate well and meet deadlines | Give advance notice when a deliverable will be delayed. |
| He rarely stops listening to others | Let others finish before you reply |
Which rating scale should be used?
The scale is half the question. There are three common options, and each has a different cost.
| Scale type | Example of options | When is it convenient | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agreement (5-point Likert) | Completely disagree… Completely agree | Short questionnaires that everyone knows. | Each evaluator interprets "according" in their own way |
| Frequency | Never, Rarely, Sometimes, Often, Always | Behaviors that are repeated on a daily basis | It can inflate responses if the evaluator sees little of the person. |
| Anchored in behaviors (BARS) | Each level describes a specific behavior. | Critical skills and processes with consequences | It requires more design work |
The five-point agreement scale is by far the most widely used in 360-degree assessments, but Bracken and colleagues point out its weakness: it doesn't give the evaluator a frame of reference, so everyone applies their own judgment. Frequency scales reduce this somewhat. Behavior-anchored scales, proposed by Smith and Kendall in 1963, They reduce it further, because each point describes a specific behavior of a different level of effectiveness.
Two details that improve any scale:
- Include the option «"I haven't been able to observe it"», outside of the average calculation. Without it, those who don't know answer with a 3 and dilute the result.
- Maintain the same scale throughout the questionnaire and in all applications, in order to be able to compare over time.
Examples of 360 questions on leadership, communication, and teamwork
The following questions are written on a frequency scale and in the third person. Choose the ones that fit your needs. competency model and replace the examples with situations from your company.
Leadership
- Explain to your team the objective and the reason for the priorities of the quarter.
- Delegate tasks with the necessary context and autonomy to do them well.
- Give concrete recognition when someone does a good job.
- Make difficult decisions in a reasonable time even if you don't have all the information.
- Ask your team for their opinion before changing a way of working that affects them.
For positions with direct reports, this block is often combined with a potential assessment, such as a leadership skills test for internal promotion decisions.
Communication
- He presents his ideas clearly and in an organized manner in meetings.
- Let others finish before you reply.
- Adapt the level of detail to your listener.
- Share information in a timely manner that others need to move forward.
- Write emails and messages that are understood the first time.
Teamwork and collaboration
- She offers help to colleagues in other areas when she sees that they need it.
- He fulfills the commitments he makes to the team.
- Address disagreements directly with the person involved.
- Publicly acknowledges the work of others in shared achievements.
- Share knowledge instead of keeping it to yourself.
Examples of 360 questions on outcomes, decisions, and adaptability
This second section covers competencies primarily observed by the direct supervisor and internal clients. The same frequency scale applies to all of them.
Results-oriented
- Set clear priorities when there are several urgent tasks.
- Give advance notice when a deliverable will be delayed and propose alternatives.
- Follow up on agreements until they are finalized.
- Review what didn't go well and adjust your work methods.
- Maintains quality of work under time pressure.
Problem solving and decision making
- Find the cause of a problem before proposing solutions.
- Consider several options and their risks before deciding.
- Consult people with relevant information before making a decision.
- Explain the criteria you used to make a decision.
Adaptability and learning
- He remains calm and effective when priorities change.
- Ask for feedback on your own work.
- Try new ways of doing things when the current ones don't work.
- Apply what you learned in the training to your work.
People development
- Dedicate time to development conversations with your team.
- Give specific and timely feedback, not just in the annual evaluation.
- Assign challenges that help others grow.
Internal customer focus
- Respond to requests within the agreed timeframes.
- Ask what is needed before proposing a solution.
- It provides information on the status of an order without you having to ask.
Many of these behaviors are soft skills. If you want to measure them with a standardized instrument, a soft skills test It provides complementary information to that of the perception of others.
How to adapt the questions to each group of evaluators?
Not everyone sees the same thing. It's best to maintain the same underlying approach and adjust the wording or remove items depending on who is responding.
| Cluster | What to evaluate | Example of writing |
|---|---|---|
| Self-assessment | All competitions | «"I explain the reasons for the priorities to my team."» |
| Direct supervisor | Results, criteria, priorities, development | «"Proposes solutions before escalating a problem"» |
| Peers | Collaboration, communication, reliability | «"He fulfills the commitments he makes to the team."» |
| Collaborators in charge | Leadership, delegation, feedback, treatment | «"It gives me concrete feedback on my work"» |
| Internal clients | Service, timing, clarity | «"Respond to my requests within the agreed timeframes"» |
The self-assessment is in the first person and uses exactly the same items as the rest, in order to be able to compare. The differences between how a person sees themselves and how others see them These are what the report highlights: Hirint's 360, for example, compares both perspectives to point out strengths, blind spots, and areas for improvement.
What open-ended questions should be included?
Open-ended questions provide examples that explain the numbers. Two or three at the end of the questionnaire are enough; any more, and people stop answering or repeat themselves. Some that work well:
- What does this person do that we should see more often?
- What one or two things would you recommend they start doing?
- What should I stop doing because it's holding the team back?
- He recounts a recent situation in which his actions made a difference, for better or for worse.
- If I had to work on just one competition this year, which one would it be and why?
To ensure the feedback is useful, the following instructions help: ask for behaviors and examples, not judgments about the person, and remember that the text will be displayed as is and anonymously. The person submitting the report will later need those examples to... turning feedback into a growth tool.
How many questions should the questionnaire have?
Less than it seems. An evaluator who answers for several colleagues gets tired, and that fatigue shows in lackluster responses. A practical guide:
- Choose between five and eight skills that really matter for the position or level.
- Write three to five items per competency. Six competencies with five items each yield 30 statements, an extension that can be answered in a reasonable amount of time.
- Add two or three open-ended questions in the end.
- Test the questionnaire with a pilot group of five or six people: time how long they take, ask which questions they didn't understand and which ones they couldn't answer.
- Review the data from the first application. Items that almost everyone rates the same or that many mark as "not observed" are candidates to be rewritten or removed.
If your competency model is not yet defined or you have very specific positions, you can start with a battery of competency tests or design custom tests that measure the same as the 360 observes, to compare both sources.
If you want to see what your 360 questionnaire and report would look like, at Hirint we can show you with your own competency model.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is 360 feedback?
It's a process in which a person receives structured feedback from various sources: their direct supervisor, peers, direct reports, and sometimes internal clients, in addition to self-evaluation. It's primarily used for professional development because it reveals how others perceive their work performance and where that perception differs from their own.
How many questions should a 360 feedback have?
There's no fixed number. A practical approach is to choose between five and eight competencies, with three to five items each, plus two or three open-ended questions. If the questionnaire is too long, evaluators responding for multiple colleagues become fatigued, and their answers lose nuance. A pilot test helps adjust the length before launch.
Is a 5-point scale or a frequency scale better?
It depends on the use. The five-point agreement scale is the most well-known, but each evaluator interprets it in their own way. The frequency scale works well for everyday behaviors. If the 360-degree scale will have significant consequences, a behavior-based scale provides more clarity, although it requires more design work.
Should the questions be the same for all evaluators?
The behavior being assessed must be the same for comparison purposes, but not all groups can answer every question. The wording is adjusted (first person in the self-assessment) and items that a group cannot observe, such as delegation in the case of peers, are removed. This prevents blind responses.
How do you write a useful open-ended question?
Ask for specific behaviors and examples, not general opinions about the person. Phrases like "what should they start doing," "what should they stop doing," or "tell us about a recent situation" generate actionable feedback. It's best to limit these to two or three phrases and remind the user in the instructions that the text will be anonymous and displayed exactly as written.