A succession plan is the process of identifying critical positions within a company, identifying potential successors, and preparing them in advance so that a departure doesn't disrupt operations. It's developed in a few steps: selecting the positions, defining the requirements of each, forming a pool of potential successors, assessing their readiness, and providing them with a development plan and ongoing support.
Well done, the succession plan is also a tool for internal mobility: shows the collaborators that there are a path to growth within the company. In this guide you will see which positions require it, the step-by-step process, how to assess the preparedness of each successor, and the most common mistakes.
Table of Contents
What is a succession plan?
The CIPD, the UK's professional human resources association, defines succession planning as Identify and develop talent to fill critical business positions in the future.. In practice, two approaches coexist:
- Replacement for positionFor each key position, one or more people are nominated who could assume it in the short or long term. This is the classic approach for general management and top management levels.
- Talent groupsPositions with similar requirements are grouped together (for example, all regional management positions) and a wider group of people are trained, who will be able to fill any of them.
Many companies combine both: nominal replacement for the five or ten most sensitive positions and talent pools for the rest of the management.
This should not be confused with the inheritance of assets in a family business, which deals with ownership. Here we are talking about who manages the business and who holds the positions on which it depends, although in a family business both issues are usually intertwined.
Why does it matter, and which positions require it?
A poorly managed transition is costly. Claudio Fernández-Aráoz, Gregory Nagel, and Carrie Green estimated in Harvard Business Review that poorly managed transitions of CEOs and senior executives at S&P 1500 companies destroy nearly one trillion dollars of market value annually.
In Mexico, the IPADE CIFEM-BBVA 2024 report, Based on responses from 476 members of family businesses, the study found that 53% of these businesses are at risk of jeopardizing their survival by not defining the timeline and process for succession in general management, and that 30% of the leaders are over 60 years old. The study itself clarifies that its sample does not represent all family businesses in the country.
Not all positions require a nominal plan. These questions will help you choose:
| Criterion | Ask | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Impact of the vacancy | What happens to revenue, customers, or operations if the position remains vacant for three months? | Plant Manager |
| Difficulty of replacement | How long would it take us to find someone outside? | Specialist in an uncommon technology |
| Concentrated knowledge | Is there information or relationships that only that person has? | Key Account Manager |
| Exit risk | Is retirement imminent or is there a high risk of turnover? | Director with retirement in two years |
Steps to develop a succession plan
- Identify the critical positions Using the criteria above, start with a short list; a plan that tries to cover everything usually falls short.
- Define the success profile for each positionExpected results, skills, technical knowledge, and values. Think about the position in the coming years, not just the current one.
- Form the group of potential successors. He asks for proposals from leaders, but also reviews those whom no one proposed (a skills inventory (helps find them): the boss's network of contacts should not decide who gets in.
- Evaluate each person's preparedness compared to the profile, with several sources of evidence (we see this in the following sections).
- Design an individual development plan to close the identified gaps, with dates and responsible parties.
- Review the plan regularly, at least once a year and whenever the strategy, structure or any of the successors change.
A Human Resources manager should coordinate the process, but the decision on each position belongs to management, who know the business and are responsible for the result.
How do you measure how prepared a successor is?
The useful question is not "who is the successor?", but "who could take over the position and in what timeframe?". That's why many companies rank each candidate by level of preparedness:
| Level | Meaning | What is usually needed |
|---|---|---|
| Ready now | He could assume the position in the coming weeks | Support during the transition |
| Ready in 1 to 2 years | He has the foundation; he's missing one or two key experiences. | Larger-scale projects, mentorship |
| Ready in 3 years or more | It has potential, but significant gaps. | Comprehensive development plan and rotations |
| Emergency coverage | It could cover temporarily, but not permanently. | Define a temporary position and look for alternatives |
For example, for a regional sales management team, the board might look like this: a deputy manager ready in one or two years, who lacks experience in negotiating with large accounts; a senior executive ready in three years or more, with solid results but no experience leading teams; and a manager from another region as emergency cover.
If a critical position has no one ready in less than two years, it's a sign to strengthen internal development or start looking for talent outside before the position becomes vacant.
How do evaluations help in choosing successors?
The readiness of a successor is often assessed based on the opinion of their boss, and that opinion is subject to bias: there's a tendency to see more potential in someone who is similar to oneself or who is closer to the boss. Standardized assessments help to compare candidates using the same criteria.
- 360 EvaluationIt gathers how the person is perceived by their superiors, peers, and colleagues. 360 evaluation It is especially useful for leadership positions, where the relationship with the team is as important as the results.
- Psychometric tests of skills and leadershipThey measure aspects such as decision-making or team management against the profile of the future position. This article explains how to use one. Leadership skills test for internal promotion.
- Structured interviews and cases: allow you to see how the person reasons in real-life situations related to the job.
For this data to be useful, the tests must have demonstrated reliability and validity, norms appropriate to the population being evaluated, and controls for social desirability bias. Even so, they are input: they complement the career path, performance, and interview, and the final decision remains with the individuals. The use of this data must comply with applicable regulations and have the informed consent of each participant.
In Hirint, the Talent Mapping It serves precisely to compare each person's capabilities with those required by a position and to detect the gaps that the development plan must close.
Development plans for successors
Naming someone as a potential successor without preparing them is just creating a list. An individual development plan translates the identified gaps into concrete actions.
- Experiences with a broader scope: lead a cross-functional project, cover for the incumbent during their vacation, or take charge of a small region.
- Mentoring by the incumbent or another executive, with regular meetings and agreed topics.
- Rotations by areas that the future position needs to know, such as finance or operations.
- Formal training in areas where experience doesn't cover well, for example finance for managers coming from sales.
Each action needs a deadline and a way to track progress. A new 360-degree assessment or skills review after a year shows whether the gap is closing. For more information, you can consult How to build a development plan for potential leaders and the webinar on How to develop leaders within companies.
Common mistakes when planning succession
- Choose by seniority, kinship or affinity instead of doing so with explicit performance criteria, skills and potential.
- Having only one candidate per position. If that person leaves or doesn't move forward, the plan falls apart.
- Promise the position. Telling someone that "they will be the next director" creates expectations that are difficult to manage and can lead to their departure if it doesn't happen.
- Not measuring progressThe plan is reviewed once and then forgotten until the position becomes vacant.
- Forget the transitionEven with the successor ready, the handover needs a period of knowledge transfer, contacts, and open decision-making.
- Leaving out some of the talentIf successor groups are formed only with informal proposals, the same profiles tend to be repeated.
If you'd like to review how to evaluate potential successors for your critical roles using comparable data, you can schedule a meeting with the Hirint team.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a succession plan in a company?
It's the process of identifying critical positions, detecting potential candidates, and preparing them in advance. This includes selection criteria, an assessment of each candidate's qualifications, development plans, and regular reviews. It's not limited to CEO or family businesses; it also applies to managers and specialists responsible for operational success.
When should a succession plan begin?
Before it becomes necessary. The clearest signs are an impending retirement, rapid growth, dependence on a single person, or a lack of internal replacements for a key position. Preparing a successor for a management role typically takes one or more years, so waiting for a vacancy leaves few options.
How many successors should each critical position have?
It's advisable to have more than one person, ideally with different levels of experience: someone who could take over quickly and someone with longer-term potential. For positions with similar demands, a shared talent pool reduces the risk that the departure of just one person will leave the plan without options.
Should a person be told that they are a possible successor?
It depends on the company culture, but it's best to discuss the development plan and growth opportunities without promising a specific position. The person needs to know that the company is investing in them and what is expected of them; an explicit promise can lead to frustration if circumstances change or the selection process leads to another candidate.
What tests are used to evaluate a successor?
It depends on the position. For leadership roles, assessments typically combine 360-degree feedback, psychometric tests of competencies and leadership skills, and structured interviews with job-related case studies. For technical roles, knowledge tests are added. The tests must have proven validity and reliability and be used with informed consent, as a complement to the assessment of professional experience and performance.