A performance evaluation form is the document where the manager and employee record what was expected during the period, what was achieved, the evidence provided, and what is agreed upon for the next period. A good form has seven sections: general information, objectives with indicators and weighting, competencies described as behaviors, a scale with definitions, calculation of the result, comments from both parties, and a plan of agreements with dates. Below you have a complete example to copy, variations by job level, and a guide for filling it out thoughtfully and connecting it to the [missing information - likely a specific context or context]. performance management of the rest of the year.
Table of Contents
What should a performance evaluation form include?
The format allows two different people, given the same performance, to arrive at a similar score and be able to explain it. For this, the following elements are needed:
- Identification data: collaborator, position, area, date of entry into the position, evaluator and period evaluated.
- Objectives for the period: each with its indicator, the goal agreed at the beginning, its weight and the actual result.
- Competencies: few and linked to the position, each one written as observable behavior and not as an adjective.
- Rating scale: with a written definition for each level, not just numbers.
- Slide rule: how the block and total grades are obtained.
- Evidence and comments: concrete examples from the evaluator and space for the collaborator's opinion.
- Development plan and agreements: actions, responsible parties, follow-up dates and signatures.
If you're looking for a public figure in Mexico, the Guidelines for the evaluation of the performance of public servants of the Federal Public Administration, The guidelines, published in the Official Gazette of the Federation (DOF) in 2005, required at a minimum parameters, indicators, evaluation factors, the procedure for calculating the total result, and the data identifying the person being evaluated and their evaluators. These rules were for the federal public sector, not for private companies, but the list serves as good proof that your form is complete.
Example format: general and objective data
This example is designed for an annual evaluation with a mid-year review. You can transfer it directly to a spreadsheet or a text document. We've divided it into two parts to make it easier to read.
Section 1. General Information
| Field | What to note |
|---|---|
| Contributor's name | Full name |
| Position and area | As stated in the job description |
| Date of entry into the position | To find out how much of the period the role occupied |
| Evaluator | Direct supervisor who observed the work during the period |
| Evaluation period | For example, January 1st to December 31st |
| Type of evaluation | Annual, semi-annual, end of probationary period |
| Date of conversation | Day on which the format is reviewed with the collaborator |
Section 2. Period Objectives (60 % of the result)
| Aim | Indicator and target | Weight | Result achieved | Rating (1 to 5) | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reduce customer response time | Average hours per ticket; goal: 24 h | 40 % | 26 h | 3 | Ticketing system report, December |
| Implement a new monthly closing process | Process documented and in use; target: June | 35 % | In use since May | 4 | Published manual and closing minutes |
| Train two new team members | Both operate without supervision; goal: 3 months | 25 % | One succeeded, another is in progress | 3 | Training record |
The weights of the objectives add up to 100 % within their block. Three to five objectives are usually sufficient; with more, each one weighs so little that it ceases to guide the work.
Example format: competencies, agreements and signatures
Section 3. Competencies (40 % of the result)
| Competence | Behavior that corresponds to a 3 (meets expectations) | Rating (1 to 5) | Example observed in the period |
|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Orientation | Respond within the agreed timeframe and confirm that the problem has been resolved. | ||
| Teamwork | Share information in a timely manner and support colleagues when the area needs it. | ||
| Quality of work | Delivery without errors that require redoing the task in most cases | ||
| Communication | Report progress and risks before they become problems |
Each competency rating requires an example from the relevant period. If the evaluator cannot find one, it indicates insufficient information to rate that behavior.
Section 4. Comments
Strengths and areas for improvement, each with an example, and a space for the employee to leave their feedback on the evaluation.
Section 5. Development plan and agreements
| Agreement | Concrete action | Responsible | Review date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Improve response time | Priority management course and weekly ticket review | Collaborator and boss | March 31 |
| Prepare the next role | Leading the closing of a quarter with support | Boss | June 30 |
Section 6. Signatures
Signature of the contributor, the evaluator, and, if your process requires it, the evaluator's supervisor. It's important to clarify in the form itself that the contributor's signature indicates they were aware of the result, not that they agree with it.
How to define the scale and calculate the rating
The simplest scale to use is the five-level scale, provided that each level has a definition that all evaluators interpret the same way.
| Level | Name | Definition |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Outstanding | He consistently and clearly surpasses the goal; his work serves as a reference for others. |
| 4 | It exceeds expectations. | It meets the goal and surpasses it in some relevant aspects |
| 3 | It meets expectations. | Achieve the agreed goal with the required quality |
| 2 | Partially meets | Achieves part of the goal or needs frequent support to achieve it |
| 1 | It does not comply | The goal is not being met and there is insufficient progress. |
Level 3 should describe good performance, not mediocre. If evaluators interpret it as a barely passing grade, most scores will rise to 4, and the scale will cease to distinguish.
To calculate, multiply each rating by its weight and add them together. With the previous example, the objectives give (3 × 0.40) + (4 × 0.35) + (3 × 0.25) = 3.35. If the competencies average 3.5, the total rating is (3.35 × 0.60) + (3.5 × 0.40) = 3.41.
If you prefer a scale of 0 to 100, the same federal guidelines published in the Official Gazette of the Federation They used four levels: outstanding from 90 to 100, satisfactory from 75 to 89.9, minimum passing from 60 to 74.9 and non-passing below 60. Whichever scale you choose, write it on the form so that the collaborator knows from the beginning how they will be rated.
Format variations according to job level
The structure remains the same; what changes is the weight of each block and the type of competitions.
| Level | Suggested weight (goals / competencies) | Usual skills | What to take care of |
|---|---|---|---|
| Operation | 50 / 50 | Quality, adherence to procedures, safety, teamwork | Indicators that the employee controls; do not measure them by results that depend on other areas |
| Supervisor or middle management | 60 / 40 | Work organization, team development, communication, problem solving | Include a goal about your team, not just about your individual output. |
| Managerial or executive | 70 / 30 | Business vision, decision-making, leadership, change management | Objectives linked to the strategy and evidence of how they were achieved, not just the result |
These weights are a starting point. The cited federal guidelines followed a similar logic: the goals were weighted at 70 % for directors and 60 % for assistant directors, department heads, and liaisons.
For middle managers and executives, it is often very beneficial to combine the opinions of peers and the team with a 360 evaluation, The format can include this as an additional piece of evidence. For people on probation, a short version is sufficient: three learning objectives and the basic skills for the position.
How to fill out the form fairly
The quality of the assessment depends less on the template design than on how to use it throughout the year. These steps help make the result defensible:
- Submit the form at the beginning of the period. Objectives, weights and scale are agreed beforehand, not at the end.
- Record evidence throughout the year. Monthly notes with concrete facts avoid simply describing what happened in recent weeks.
- Ask for a self-assessment. The employee fills in their version before the conversation; the differences with the boss's version are the best starting point for discussion.
- Rate with evidence. Each number is accompanied by an example or a piece of data.
- Calibrate before communicating. The heads of an area review their ratings together to unify criteria.
- Talk, don't just hand it over. Reviewing the format requires a meeting with ample time, not an email with a PDF. The way you give feedback is just as important as the grade; here are some ideas for... turning feedback into a growth tool.
- Close with agreements and dates. Without follow-up, the development plan remains just on paper.
It also sets a minimum observation time. In the federal public sector Six continuous months in the position were required for the annual evaluation and three for the semi-annual evaluation; in your company the figure may be different, but it should be written down.
How to reduce bias when rating
The most frequent errors when filling out a form are well known: the halo effect (one outstanding quality contaminates all ratings), the central tendency (giving everyone a 3 to avoid arguments), the indulgence or systematic severity of certain bosses, and the recency bias.
The most studied remedy is to train evaluators using a common frame of reference: reviewing performance examples together, deciding what rating each deserves, and explaining why. analysis published in 2024 in Industrial and Organizational Psychology, The SIOP journal found that this type of training is especially useful for identifying underperformance, and that the environment in which it is delivered hardly changes its effect. A calibration session for each area before communicating results serves a similar purpose. If you want to delve deeper, this Webinar on how to identify and mitigate biases in HR processes. discuss the topic with specialists in the field.
It also helps to separate the sources of information. If, in addition to the boss's judgment, you have data from competency tests Applied with the same criteria to the entire team, the conversation is based on more than just an impression. No test replaces observation of the work: it complements it.
What to do with the evaluation results
A well-filled form informs decisions about training and development, promotions and internal mobility. For this to happen, the agreements in section 5 must be reviewed on the agreed dates and recorded in the following format. The evaluation is another stage of the cycle that goes from the initial interview to the performance evaluation, and works best when connected to the previous ones.
The evaluation also has a well-being side. NOM-035-STPS-2018 of the STPS It includes performance evaluation and recognition among the elements of a favorable organizational environment, and among its preventative measures, it mentions recognizing outstanding performance. A clear process, with rules known from the outset, contributes to such an environment; an opaque one does the opposite.
At Hirint, we approach performance management with this focus: consistent criteria for all evaluators, evidence that complements the manager's perception, and results that lead to development actions. The final decision remains with the individuals. If you'd like to see how this could be applied to your team, you can schedule a meeting with us.
Frequently Asked Questions
What fields should a performance evaluation form have?
At a minimum, the following information is required: details of the employee and the evaluator, the evaluation period, objectives with indicators, targets, weighting, and results, competencies described as behaviors, a scale with definitions for each level, the calculation method, comments from both parties, and a plan outlining agreements with responsible parties and deadlines. Signatures close the document and confirm that the employee was informed of the result.
How often should performance evaluations be conducted?
The standard practice is an annual performance review with a mid-year follow-up review. For roles with short cycles, such as sales or project management, a quarterly review of objectives works better. The important thing is that the evaluator has observed the work for a sufficient period and that the employee is aware of the timeline from the beginning of the period.
Which rating scale is better?
There is no single ideal scale for all companies. The five-level scale is easy to use and provides a midpoint that represents meeting expectations. Scales from 0 to 100 offer more detail but require clearly defining each range. In any case, each level needs a written description so that two evaluators can interpret it in the same way.
Can I create the performance evaluation form in Excel?
Yes. A spreadsheet works well for small teams: one tab per section, formulas for weighted averages, and protected cells for weights and scales. As the number of collaborators grows, consolidating files, calibrating across departments, and tracking agreements becomes more complex, and a tool that centralizes information is often preferable.
Can performance evaluations be used to fire someone?
It can be a relevant factor, but it shouldn't be the sole criterion. Any decision of this kind must comply with the Federal Labor Law, the employment contract, and the company's internal regulations, according to the applicable law in each case; it's advisable to review it with labor law advice. A documented format with evidence, prior agreements, and follow-up shows that the employee was aware of what was expected of them.