The Kostick test, known internationally as PAPI (Personality and Preference Inventory), is a workplace personality questionnaire: it describes how a person prefers to work, what motivates them at work, and how they tend to behave with bosses, colleagues, and tasks. It does not measure aptitudes or knowledge, and in personnel selection, it serves as a complement to the CV and the interview, provided that a version with a manual is used and the person interpreting it is trained to do so.
This guide, designed for HR teams considering using the test, explains what it measures, what tests can replace it (starting with Hirint's), and then how to administer it and what the evidence says. It does not include test items or scoring keys.
Table of Contents
What is the Kostick test and where did it come from?
The inventory is named after Max Kostick, an American industrial psychologist credited with its design in the 1960s. In English-language literature, it appears as the Perception and Preference Inventory or the Personality and Preference Inventory, and in Mexico, it is known as the «Kostick test» or the «Kostick perception inventory.».
Its theoretical basis is Henry Murray's theory of needs. A study of Sanz and colleagues (2006) He describes it as a questionnaire based on Murray's need-pressure theory, designed to assess needs and relevant behavioral patterns at work and developed primarily for personnel selection.
The instrument has changed over the years. The entrance of Leaetta Hough (2017) The Encyclopedia of Personality and Individual Differences indicates that the PAPI is in its third edition (PAPI 3), is available in 29 languages, and has 22 main scales and 10 facet scales grouped into 7 factors, plus 5 items that measure social desirability. Its technical manuals were published by the British consulting firm Cubiks.
This matters in Mexico: much of what circulates on the internet as «Kostick test» are copies of old versions, without an identified publisher or updated manual.
What does the Kostick test measure?
The PAPI measures preferences and work styles, not abilities. Broadly speaking, its scales are grouped into areas such as:
- Work address: how the person relates to goals, achievements, and finishing what they start.
- Leadership and relationship with authority: whether you prefer to lead, follow instructions, or work independently.
- Work style: order, attention to detail and a preference for structured or varied tasks.
- Social relationships: need to belong to a group and to have contact with other people.
- Rhythm and temperament: level of activity and way of managing emotions at work.
The fact that it measures preferences and not capabilities has empirical support. Furnham and Craig (1987) They found that five of the seven PAPI subscale scores correlated with extraversion, and that there were very few significant correlations with a reasoning test. In other words, the PAPI is more like a personality questionnaire than an intelligence test.
It is also not a clinical test: it is not useful for detecting disorders or for knowing if someone is lying.
Which Hirint tests can replace the Kostick test?
If you're looking to understand how someone works, you don't need a PAPI. Hirint's library offers over 70 tests with reports and scoring systems. They aren't scale-for-scale equivalents to the PAPI, but they cover the same things a company typically seeks to understand with it:
| What DADDY looks at | Hirint Test | Duration | What does it contribute? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Work direction: goals, achievement, finishing what you start | soft skills | 12 min | Between 4 and 34 competencies, fit to the job profile and candidate ranking |
| Leadership and relationship with authority | Leadership Skills | 11 min | Transformational, transactional, and adaptive leadership, with a global index |
| Work style: order and detail | Personality | 5 min | The five major factors, including responsibility (organization and discipline) |
| Social relationships and style with others | DISC | 6 min | Four-factor profile, with natural behaviors and under pressure |
| Rhythm and emotional management | emotional intelligence | 9 min | 14 emotional competencies in four dimensions, such as self-awareness and self-management |
| Fit with the organization (PAPI does not measure this) | Values and Culture and Mentality | 5 and 10 min | The fit of the person with the values and culture that the company seeks |
Two differences compared to a PAPI copied from the internet address its most well-known problems. The Soft Skills test detects social desirability bias, which is the risk that the candidate will answer in order to present a positive image. And the Personality test asks for the level of agreement with each statement, a format that allows for comparison between candidates, something the ipsative version of the PAPI does not do well (explained below).
To compare the questionnaire with real behavior, the AI-powered STAR Video Interview (15 min) assesses up to three competencies with behavioral questions and points out the evidence that justifies each level.
What other alternatives are there to the Kostick test?
| Tool | What does it contribute? | When to choose it |
|---|---|---|
| 16PF Test | Sixteen long-standing personality factors | When looking for more detail than five features |
| Test Cleaver | Four-factor behavioral style, with forced choice as the PAPI | For team conversations and communication style |
| Structured behavioral interview | Real-life examples of how the person acted | Always, as a contrast to any questionnaire |
You can delve deeper into the differences between Big Five and DISC, in it 16PF test or in the Cleaver test.
How is it applied? Ipsative version and normative version
There are two formats, and it's important to know which one is being used because they change the conclusions that can be drawn:
| Aspect | Ipsative version (PAPI-I) | Normative version (PAPI-N) |
|---|---|---|
| Format | The person chooses which of two phrases best describes them. | The person rates each phrase on an agreement scale |
| What compares | A person's preferences among themselves | To the person with a reference group |
| What is it most useful for? | Individual feedback and development | Comparing candidates in a selection process |
| Main limitation | It does not allow for a good comparison between people. | It needs updated standards that are appropriate for the country. |
The difference is not insignificant. In a classic article on ipsative tests, Johnson, Wood and Blinkhorn (1988) They warn that claims about the usefulness of ipsative tests for comparing individuals are misleading, and that treating them as normative measures has serious consequences. If the goal is to rank or filter several people, an ipsative version is not the appropriate tool.
The person responds individually, on paper or online depending on the version, and the rating and report depend on the version and the publisher. test use guidelines from the International Test Commission They recommend avoiding tests with insufficient or unclear technical documentation, respecting copyright, and not distributing test materials; therefore, no reagents or answer keys are reproduced here.
What does the evidence say about its reliability and validity?
Published evidence on the PAPI is more limited than that for other personality questionnaires, but it does exist:
- Reliability of the Spanish version. Sanz and colleagues (2006) analyzed the Spanish version of the PAPI-N with 420 job applicants and 201 volunteers. Internal consistency was adequate in both samples and similar to that of the original version, and factor analysis partially supported its structure, with five dimensions that were repeated in both samples.
- Relationship with the Big Five. In another study, Sanz and colleagues (2008) They compared the PAPI-N with the NEO-FFI in 91 working people and 71 psychology students with work experience. Most of what the PAPI-N measures could be organized within the five-factor model, although it also included aspects that this model does not cover.
- Falsification of answers. In the study by Furnham and Craig (1987), just over half of the items showed significant differences between those who responded truthfully and those who were trying to present a good or bad image. In selection processes, where everyone wants to make a good impression, this risk exists.
There are two gaps to keep in mind. The cited studies analyze the questionnaire's structure and its relationship to other tests, not how well it predicts performance in a specific job. And we couldn't find any published studies with norms for the Mexican population. Before using it, ask the provider for evidence of a correlation with performance and norms specific to your country.
When does it make sense to use it in the national team in Mexico?
The Kostick test can provide useful information if these conditions are met:
- You use a version with an editor and manual. Copies without a clear origin have no verifiable standards or evidence of validity.
- You choose the version that is appropriate for the objective. The regulations for comparing candidates; the ipsative for development conversations.
- It is interpreted by someone who is trained. The ITC guidelines They require that the interpreter be familiar with the theoretical basis of the test, its scales, its comparison groups, and its limitations.
- You use it as an accessory. The PAPI profile is used to prepare interview questions, not to approve or reject anyone on its own.
- You inform the person. Explain what the test is for, who will see the results, and how your data is protected, according to applicable regulations in Mexico.
- You control social desirability. Contrast the profile with concrete examples of behavior in the interview, because the answers can be faked.
If you cannot meet several of these conditions, it is more prudent to use one of the alternatives above.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the Kostick test measure?
It measures preferences and behavioral patterns at work: how a person relates to goals, authority, order, social relationships, and work pace. It is based on Murray's theory of needs. It does not measure intelligence, knowledge, or clinical traits, so its result describes a work style and does not indicate whether someone is capable of performing a job.
How is the Kostick test interpreted?
It's interpreted as a profile, not a grade. The analyst reviews which preferences stand out, compares them with the job requirements, and, in the standardized version, with a reference group. The interpretation is the responsibility of a trained individual familiar with the manual for the version used. The result helps prepare for the interview and compare the profile with real-world examples.
What are the correct answers to the Kostick test?
There are no right or wrong answers: it's a preference questionnaire, and each candidate may be a better fit for some positions than others. The «answers» circulating online are often copied versions, and sharing them goes against best practices for test use. Furthermore, answering with the intention of creating a positive image can be detected using social desirability scales and during the interview.
What is the difference between PAPI-I and PAPI-N?
The PAPI-I is ipsative: the person chooses between pairs of phrases, and the result compares their preferences with each other, useful for feedback and development. The PAPI-N is normative: each phrase is rated on a scale, and the result is compared to a reference group, allowing for comparison of candidates if appropriate norms exist for the country.
If you want to assess how your candidates work with a test that controls for social desirability, check out the Hirint soft skills test.