The Cleaver test is a self-report assessment based on the DISC model that describes behavioral styles at work. It can be used to initiate conversations about how a person behaves, but public evidence regarding its reliability and validity is limited. Before using it for hiring decisions, it's advisable to request technical documentation and compare it with other options.
Table of Contents
What is the Cleaver test and what does it measure?
The Cleaver asks the person to describe themselves and returns a four-factor profile. It does not measure intelligence, knowledge, or technical skills. Nor does it offer an in-depth personality analysis: it describes behavioral tendencies based on the respondent's own perception.
In Mexico, it circulates under names that do not always coincide with those of other DISC tests: those in the Cleaver column are the ones collected by a UNAM thesis. If you're comparing suppliers, it's helpful to understand this equivalence:
| Letter | Common name in the Cleaver | Common name in the DISC model | What does it describe, broadly speaking? |
|---|---|---|---|
| D | Domain | Dominance | How to face challenges and take the initiative |
| I | Influence | Influence | How to relate and persuade |
| yes | Constancy | Stability | Rhythm, patience, and a preference for continuity |
| C | Attachment | Consciousness | Attention to thoroughness, analysis, and standards |
The letter C is the one that generates the most confusion. The same factor appears as attachment, compliance, or conscientiousness depending on the material, and that can change how a recruiter interprets it. When comparing reports, review the definition of each scale, not just its name.
Where does it come from and what is its relationship to the DISC model?
DISC is a behavioral model; the Cleaver is one of the instruments built upon it. The starting point is Marston's 1928 work, which the article on the DISC test in personnel selection Explain in more detail.
The history of the instrument is not entirely clear. That undergraduate thesis, from 2002, places its origins in a program initiated in 1960 at Reading Tube Co., developed by J.P. Cleaver and Richard B. Doss. The history published by Everything DiSC mentions another piece: an instrument called Self-Description, created for John Cleaver by Walter Clarke's firm and converted into a forced-choice test with 24 tetrads. Dates vary depending on the source, so it's best to read them with caution.
For HR, there's a practical consequence: sharing a name doesn't guarantee that two versions are equivalent. The same study from UNAM didn't locate a formal manual and observed different scoring templates between institutions, in addition to companies that changed words on the test. Another UANL Master's Thesis of 2011 Yes, it cites a 1961 manual published in Mexico. That's why it's important to ask the supplier for the manual for the exact version they will be selling.
How is the Cleaver test administered and interpreted?
The technique described in the UNAM thesis It consists of two questionnaires: one on job perception, completed by the immediate supervisor, and another on self-description, completed by the person being evaluated. The format is forced-choice: in each series of four words, the respondent marks which word they most identify with and which they least identify with. This article does not reproduce the items, templates, or scoring keys: these are subject to copyright, and their distribution affects the validity of the test.
The process usually follows these steps:
- Define what the position requires before seeing results, with someone who knows it well.
- Inform the person about the purpose of the evaluation and the processing of their data.
- Apply the purchased version, under the same conditions for all candidates.
- Review the profile with someone trained to interpret it, using the manual for that version.
- Contrast what appears in the profile with concrete examples in a structured interview.
The report is typically organized into three graphs. According to this theory, M reflects intrinsic motivation, L reflects limitations and response under pressure, and T reflects natural behavior. The analysis is conducted in relation to the job requirements and never against an ideal profile based on the interviewer's preference.
In terms of duration, the sources consulted mention half an hour or less, depending on the version. The UNAM thesis describes a paper application that is somewhat shorter than the one advertised by online providers.
What does the evidence say about the Cleaver test?
A search of open sources, not intended to be exhaustive, located the two Mexican theses cited and a peer-reviewed article that touches on Cleaver only secondarily. It found no journal studies dedicated to its predictive validity. This does not prove that such studies do not exist: they may be found in manuals or private reports, and therefore it is advisable to request them.
Reliability. The UNAM thesis The self-report questionnaire was administered to 100 nursing graduates. The complete test yielded a coefficient of -0.14, while the Influence and Attachment scales yielded -0.03 and -0.17, respectively. After removing items, the four scales ranged from 0.40 to 0.48, with between 4 and 12 items. The authors conclude that, in this population, the Cleaver was not a reliable tool, and add that their search at the time yielded no record of the technique in organizations such as the APA or Buros.
Relationship with performance. The UANL thesis A study compared 76 high-performing telephone service executives with 11 low-performing executives at a financial company. It found no significant differences in Cleaver scores between the two groups. Within the high-performing group, a regression analysis associated Influence on Motivated Behavior with a better score, with a moderate effect. In another sample, a Article from 2024 in Accounting and Administration The Cleaver, Terman, and PIPG were analyzed to select 147 vehicle salespeople, and their correlation with the average daily commission was not significant.
What to do with this data. None of these studies allow for generalization: the samples are very specific, two are theses, and the article does not report the coefficient for each test. They do, however, justify a cautious approach. Furthermore, the format is also a factor: Brown and Maydeu-Olivares (2013) They explain that forced-choice questionnaires scored using the classic method produce ipsative data, which distorts the relationships between scales and makes it difficult to compare one person to another. This is a significant limitation if you plan to rank candidates based on their profile, and it can also affect coefficients such as those mentioned above.
What can it be used for and what can't it be used for in selection?
Given that evidence, the most defensible use of Cleaver is descriptive. International Test Commission It calls for using tests for purposes supported by sufficient validity evidence, and that criterion applies here as well.
| Use | Prudent assessment |
|---|---|
| Prepare interview questions | Reasonable, if the profile only guides what to explore |
| Discuss work style and integration plan | Reasonable, especially with feedback to the person |
| Compare to a job profile | With caution: it requires a well-defined profile and a documented version. |
| Ranking applications or setting a cut-off score | Hardly defensible without local validity studies |
| Using it as the sole hiring criterion | Not recommended |
| Evaluate technical capacity | Not applicable: requires further testing |
If the question is what someone knows how to do, the competency tests And the work samples best answer that question. A broader view of the options is in this guide. psychometric tests for work. The final decision remains human and is also based on the CV and the interview.
Cleaver or a validated DISC test: how to decide?
«"Validated" is a word that needs to be clarified: a test is validated for a specific use and population, not generally. To decide, ask the same questions to any provider of Cleaver or another DISC test:
| What to ask | What to order | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Which version should I use? | Author, edition, date and manual | No one can identify the origin |
| Does it measure consistently? | Scale reliability, with method and sample | A global figure without details |
| What proves its validity? | Performance studies or other tests | Only testimonials or number of users |
| Who do I compare myself to? | Recent standards and population of Mexico or similar | Rules without a date or of unknown origin |
| How does it deal with forced choice? | Scoring method and limits when comparing people | Rankings without explanation |
| Who interprets the data and how is it protected? | Training, privacy notice and security | Automated report submitted as verdict |
The result could be to keep the Cleaver for descriptive purposes if the documentation convinces you, switch to another DISC test, or add another approach. If you're unsure between models, comparing them Big Five and DISC It helps to separate what each one contributes.
Hirint has a DISC test with automated reports which is part of a battery of tests. You can meet him and ask him the same questions from the table.
What precautions should be taken when applying it in Mexico?
The Federal Law on the Protection of Personal Data Held by Private Parties It requires providing the individual with a privacy notice outlining the purposes of the data processing. While tacit consent is generally accepted, explicit written consent is required for sensitive personal data, a category that includes data whose misuse could lead to discrimination. Your legal team should assess how the results of these tests fit into your policy.
In practice, it helps to document the purpose of the test, who sees the results, how long they are kept, and how the person can exercise their rights. The results should also not be used for discrimination. This text is for guidance only and does not replace legal advice in accordance with applicable regulations.
If you're comparing similar instruments, this might also be helpful. How to apply a DISC test in selection and What does the 16PF test measure?.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Cleaver test the same as the DISC test?
Not exactly. DISC is the model, and the Cleaver is one of the instruments that uses it. They share the four-factor logic, but may differ in scale names, items, norms, and scoring methods. Therefore, results from one test should not be transferred to another without reviewing the technical documentation of each.
How long does the Cleaver test last?
The sources consulted indicate a timeframe of half an hour or less, depending on the version. A thesis from UNAM describes a paper-based application that is somewhat shorter than the time advertised by online providers. It is advisable to allow a reasonable margin and confirm the time with the provider before including the test in the process.
Does the Cleaver test predict job performance?
There isn't enough public evidence to make a general statement. A thesis from UANL found no significant differences between high- and low-performing groups, and a study with salespeople also found no significant correlation with their commissions. If you want to use it to make a decision, request validity studies for positions and populations similar to yours.
Can I use a free PDF or template of the Cleaver test?
It is not advisable. A copy does not guarantee that the reagents, template, or norms correspond to a documented version, and the UNAM thesis detected different templates and modified wording. Furthermore, it can raise copyright issues. The most prudent approach is to work with material from an identifiable source and a readily available manual.
Is it legal to use the Cleaver test in Mexico?
No source consulted specifically prohibits its use, but it must comply with labor and data protection regulations. This includes a privacy notice, a clear purpose, obtaining the appropriate consent, and non-discrimination. If the results are used in sensitive hiring processes, consult your legal department, as this general guidance does not constitute legal advice.