For selection, the Big Five test is usually the most widely supported option: it measures five major personality traits, and its relationship to job performance has been documented in meta-analyses for decades. DISC describes behavioral styles, is easier to explain, and is useful for interview preparation and teamwork, but its ability to predict performance has been scarcely studied. Neither test is sufficient on its own.
It is one of the most common doubts in selection teams, especially when one is already in use DISC test in the processes And someone suggests moving on to the Big Five, or vice versa. The useful question isn't which one to discard, but what each one contributes and at what point in the process.
Table of Contents
What does the Big Five test measure?
The Big Five model, also called OCEAN, describes personality using five continuous dimensions. It doesn't categorize people into types; rather, each person falls somewhere along each scale.
- Openness to experienceIntellectual curiosity, imagination, interest in new ideas.
- Responsibility (conscientiousness): organization, consistency, self-discipline, and goal orientation.
- Extraversion: sociability, energy, assertiveness and seeking stimulation.
- Kindness: cooperation, trust in others and consideration.
- Emotional stabilitySerenity in the face of pressure. Its opposite pole is called neuroticism.
The model didn't originate from a single theory, but from decades of research that repeatedly identified these five dimensions in different languages and questionnaires. Today, instruments exist that delve into the details of these facets. BFI-2 of Soto and John, For example, it has 60 items and measures 15 facets, three per dimension.
One important distinction: traits are relatively stable, but not immutable. If you're interested in the debate, we discuss it in Is personality something you're born with or something you develop? Can personality change?.
What does the evidence say about the Big Five in selection?
The main argument in favor of the Big Five is that their relationship to work has been measured many times. The classic meta-analysis of Barrick and Mount (1991) It found that conscientiousness was consistently related to all performance criteria across all occupational groups studied, and that extraversion predicted performance in management and sales positions. Using European data, Jesús Salgado (1997), Researchers from the University of Santiago de Compostela found that responsibility and emotional stability were valid predictors across different criteria and occupations.
The most recent revision adjusts those figures downward. In its table of revised estimates, Sackett, Zhang, Berry and Lievens (2022) They assign a validity of 0.19 to conscientiousness when measured generally and 0.25 when the measure is contextualized in the workplace, that is, with items or instructions such as "answer thinking about how you behave at work." Emotional stability drops from 0.09 to 0.23 with this same contextualization. For reference, the structured interview reaches 0.42 and the cognitive ability tests, 0,31.
In practical terms: personality provides real but moderate information. It serves as one piece of the puzzle, not the deciding factor, and is most effective when the questions or instructions place the person within their work context.
And what evidence does DISC have?
The DISC scale is based on the model published by psychologist William Moulton Marston in 1928 and describes four dimensions: Dominance, Influence, Steadiness, and Conscientiousness (the C dimension also appears as Compliance or Conformity in other versions). Current questionnaires were developed later by other authors, and there are many different versions.
Its weakness for selection lies in predictive evidence. DISC is not among the procedures analyzed in the review by Sackett and his team, nor is it the subject of classic meta-analyses of personality and performance. That doesn't mean it's useless, but rather that its use in hiring decisions Be cautious. If a vendor claims their version predicts performance, ask for the studies.
Its strength lies elsewhere: a simple language that is easy to understand, very useful for guiding interviews, for onboarding, and for team conversations about how to communicate.
To clarify and avoid confusion: DISC's Conscientiousness and Big Five's Responsibility are similar in name (some English versions refer to the C in DISC as Conscientiousness, the same as the Big Five factor), but they are not the same scale. The former describes a style of relating to rules and data; the latter, a broad trait with facets such as orderliness and self-discipline.
Big Five vs DISC: comparison
| Criterion | Big Five | DISC |
|---|---|---|
| What describes | Broad personality traits | Behavioral and interaction styles |
| Origin | Decades of research on traits | Marston's model of emotions (1928) |
| Structure | 5 continuous dimensions, with facets | 4 dimensions combined in profiles |
| Predictive evidence in selection | Published meta-analyses; moderate validity, greater when contextualized | Scarce; it does not appear in the reference meta-analyses |
| Ease in communicating results | Media: requires explaining features and facets | High: intuitive language |
| Main risk | Reading traits without a job analysis | Convert a style into a tag |
| Best use | Selection, as a complementary predictor | Interview, onboarding and equipment |
When to use each one?
The choice depends on what the result will be used for:
- If the outcome will weigh heavily in the hiring decision, The evidence tips the scales towards an instrument based on the Big Five, with appropriate scales and instructions contextualized in the work.
- Whether the position is in sales or management, Look closely at extraversion and conscientiousness, and combine them with specific tests such as a personality test and sales skills.
- If the goal is to prepare for the interview or the onboarding process, DISC provides a practical vocabulary for discussing style with the individual and their manager.
- If you work with pre-existing teams, DISC offers a common language for talking about communication and task sharing.
- In any case, No personality test can replace the skills tests nor to the structured interview when the position requires specific knowledge or skills.
Can they be used together?
Yes, and it often makes sense, provided each test has a clear role. A common approach is to use a Big Five-based test during selection and reserve DISC for onboarding and team development. If both are used in the same process, three things should be monitored:
- The total duration. Taking two personality questionnaires in a row lengthens the process and worsens the candidate's experience.
- The double count. The influence of DISC and the extraversion of the Big Five point to similar behaviors; if both add up in the decision, that aspect weighs twice as much without anyone having decided it.
- The previous weights. Decide before you see the results what information each test will use and how much it will count.
Platforms like Hirint allow combining personality, DISC, and competency tests into a single battery, with the scientific basis of each assessment documented.
Best practices with any personality test
- Start with the job analysis. Without knowing which behaviors matter, any profile seems suitable.
- Check the technical specifications. Reliability, validity evidence, and norms with a population comparable to your candidates. In the blog we review the state of the art of psychometrics in selection.
- It has social desirability. Job applicants tend to present themselves in a favorable light. Forced-choice formats and models of item response theory They help reduce that effect.
- Do not use rigid cutting points based on a single trait.
- Do not perform clinical readings. A low score in emotional stability is not a diagnosis.
- Inform the candidate of the purpose of the test and the use of your data, according to applicable regulations.
- Leave the decision in the hands of people. that compare several sources.
If you want to see how to combine personality, DISC and skills in a real process, at Hirint we'll show you with a case study from your company.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Big Five test?
It is an assessment based on the Big Five personality model: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and emotional stability (or neuroticism, its opposite). Each factor is a continuous scale, not a type. The most comprehensive questionnaires also measure facets within each factor, allowing for a more nuanced analysis of the profile in relation to the job.
Which personality test is the most reliable for selection?
There is no single best test. What's important to compare is the technical specifications of each instrument: reliability, evidence of validity for workplace use, and norms based on a population similar to your candidates. Based on accumulated evidence, Big Five-based instruments have more support in selection than behavioral style instruments, but a poorly designed Big Five instrument won't necessarily outperform a well-constructed one of another type.
Is a personality test useful for selecting candidates?
It can provide additional information about behavioral tendencies, but it should not be used in isolation. Its validity for predicting performance is moderate, lower than that of a well-designed structured interview. It works best in combination with the CV, the interview, and skills tests, and with instructions that place the person in their work context.
Is there an ideal personality type for working?
No. The context and demands of the position determine which traits are helpful and which are not. High extroversion might be a good fit for a sales role but irrelevant for a data analysis position. Furthermore, an organization needs a diversity of profiles and ways of thinking; seeking a single profile for the entire company reduces that diversity.
Can a candidate fake a Big Five test?
You might try to present a favorable image, especially on obvious scales like responsibility. That's why good instruments include consistency indicators or use forced-choice formats, which make it harder to answer simply to look good. Even so, the most effective approach is to compare the results with concrete examples during the interview: inconsistencies between what is stated and what is actually experienced will be noticeable.