The Moss test, also called the Social Adaptability Test, is a 30-problem test with four possible answers that aims to measure how a person handles interpersonal relationships, especially in management positions. In Mexico, it has been used to select supervisors, but public evidence of its use is scarce. the UNAM thesis that calculated its reliability It yielded very low results. If you use it, it's best to treat it as a minor piece of data and compare it with other sources.
Table of Contents
What does the Moss test measure?
The test is organized into five areas, described in the technical data sheet that contains that thesis from 2002. The table summarizes what each one intends to evaluate and what source you could compare it with.
| Area | What does it intend to evaluate? | What to compare it to |
|---|---|---|
| Supervisory skills | Leading a team and achieving objectives | Structured interview about real supervisory situations |
| Decision-making ability in human relations | Choosing an option when there are people involved | Case study or simulation with job decisions |
| Assessment of interpersonal problems | Identifying what causes conflict at work | Conflict analysis exercise |
| Establishing interpersonal relationships | Adjust the treatment according to the other person | Work references or 360-degree evaluation for internal candidates |
| Common sense and tact | Respond prudently in social situations | Simulation of a difficult conversation |
There's a nuance that's often overlooked: the format asks you to choose the best answer to a written problem. Therefore, it reflects what someone thinks should be done, and that's not the same as what they actually do with their team on a challenging Tuesday. A test like this can offer a clue about judgment, but it doesn't reveal leadership.
What positions is it used for?
Its use is concentrated in command positions. The 2002 thesis describes it as part of assessment batteries for candidates for those positions and states that 8 of the 11 companies visited applied it in selection. There are eleven companies, so the data illustrates a practice and does not measure the market.
Other UNAM thesis, 2005, The study involved 310 area managers from PEMEX Refining. Both studies indicate that it is common among people with a high school education or higher.
It makes less sense for positions without direct reports, unless the profile truly requires that kind of expertise. It's not useful for technical skills; a knowledge test or a work sample is a better fit for those roles.
How is it applied and interpreted?
It is a self-administered test, which can be administered individually or in groups. version attached to the 2002 thesis It gives 20 minutes to solve the 30 problems, and the of 2005 It reports an application time of about 20 minutes. Online guides give different times, so check the manual for your version.
Broadly speaking, the grading process follows three steps:
- Each answer is compared to a key and scores a point if it matches.
- The total, and that of each area, becomes a percentile.
- The percentile translates into a range, from deficient to superior.
Step 2 is where the interpretation is most crucial, because the percentile depends on the group you're comparing it to. The 2005 thesis illustrates this well: when calculating proprietary norms with PEMEX area managers, The equivalencies between points and percentiles changed in all five areas with respect to the Spanish table that had been used. The same rating can be interpreted differently depending on the table.
We do not reproduce problems, keys, or answers here. They are protected by copyright, and if they circulate among candidates, the result no longer says anything about the person.
Where did the Moss test come from?
The authorship is unclear, and that in itself is useful information for HR. The authors of the 2002 thesis sought supporting material and They found no original sources to support it. The 2005 one was written by "Moos" and He attributes it to Bernice and Rudolf Moos, dated 1984. Several online guides spell "Moss" and give 1979.
Rudolf Moos is a real author, known for a social climate scale at work, which assesses the work environment, not an individual's skills. We couldn't find a manual or article from him documenting this test, so we can't confirm that attribution.
There is also a namesake. George Washington University social intelligence test, by Moss, Hunt and others, dating from 1927, It has its own literature in English. We found no document linking it to the evidence circulating in Mexico, so its evidence should not be transferred to that case.
What does the evidence say about its reliability and validity?
There is little available, and what is available is not favorable to the test. In our review of open access repositories, we found these two studies and did not locate any articles in scientific journals dedicated to this test.
| Study | With who | What he found | What doesn't answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| UNAM, 2002 | 430 job applicants from a service institution | Cronbach's alpha of 0.14 and 13 factors where 5 were expected. The authors conclude that its use is not recommended. | If it predicts performance |
| UNAM, 2005 | 310 PEMEX Refining area managers | Local standards different from the Spanish table | Whether the test measures what it claims to measure or predicts performance |
Three points to consider before reading this:
- These are undergraduate theses, each with a single organization. The 2002 study used a convenience sample.
- A global alpha tends to decrease when a test mixes different areas with few problems per area. Even so, 0.14 is far from the 0.80, which that thesis takes as a reference, and the five-area structure did not appear either.
- The high figure in the 2005 thesis does not contradict the above. Their coefficients from 0.957 to 0.989 They are presented as reliability of the obtained standards, not as internal consistency of the problems.
The 2002 thesis also proposes a new 26-item scale for supervision only, with an alpha of 0.73 in university students. It is a different instrument, so that data does not apply to the original test.
A cautious interpretation: there is insufficient evidence to support hiring decisions based on this test. Nor has it been demonstrated that it offers no benefit in any context, because we found no open-label studies that compare it against performance.
If your company already uses it, what should you check?
Quitting abruptly isn't always feasible. These steps will help you make an informed decision:
- Ask for the documentation. Author, year, version, and date of the standards. guidelines of the International Test Commission They ask you to verify that the technical documentation for a test is sufficient before using it. If your supplier can't provide it, you already have an answer.
- Review the comparison group. A table from another country or from decades ago may not represent your candidates.
- Analyze your own data. With the support of a psychometrics specialist, calculate the internal consistency of each area in your population.
- Compare it to the performance. Compare the results with the evaluations of current supervisors. If there's no correlation, you have grounds to remove him.
- Remove automatic cuts. No candidate should be excluded solely because of this result.
- Take care of the consent. This document explains the purpose of the test and processes the data in accordance with applicable regulations. This text is not legal advice; please consult your legal department.
How to evaluate leadership using more than one source?
A solid general reference is the meta-analysis by Sackett and colleagues, from 2022, This study reviewed the validity of selection methods for predicting performance. Its estimates cover overall performance, not leadership in particular, and vary across studies. There is no equivalent figure for the Moss test.
| Method | Estimated validity |
|---|---|
| Structured interview | 0.42 |
| Cognitive aptitude test | 0.31 |
| Assessment center | 0.29 |
| Situational judgment test | 0.26 |
| Unstructured interview | 0.19 |
Fountain: Sackett et al., 2022, Table 3.
With that in mind, a management evaluation can be structured as follows:
- Define the behaviors. What this person should do in this position: give feedback, distribute workload, handle conflict between colleagues.
- Structure the interview. Same questions for everyone, focused on past events and with a pre-agreed rating scale.
- Observe a situation. A simulated difficult conversation or a prioritization case demonstrates behavior, not just opinion.
- Add evidence with documented support. Some competency tests and one soft skills test They provide comparable results between candidates. To choose the rest of the battery, see how to select psychometric tests for work.
- If it's an internal promotion, use what you already know. A 360-degree evaluation and the performance track record brings what an external candidate cannot offer. It's a good fit within a succession plan.
- Determine how you will combine the data. Decide how much each source weighs before seeing the results. The final decision is made by people, with all the information available.
To evaluate leadership using more than one source, they help define the job skills for each level and one 180-degree evaluation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Moss test?
It is a 30-question, four-choice test, also known as the Social Adaptability Test, which aims to evaluate supervisory and interpersonal skills in five areas. In Mexico, it has been primarily used with candidates for management positions. Sources disagree on who created it or in what year.
Is the Moss test reliable?
Open evidence is limited and unfavorable. A 2002 UNAM thesis, with 430 job applicants, obtained a Cronbach's alpha of 0.14 and did not find the five expected areas. It is a single study, but it justifies seeking further evidence before basing hiring decisions on this result.
How long does the Moss test last?
The versions described in two theses from UNAM take around 20 minutes for 30 problems. Online guides suggest different times. The sensible approach is to follow the manual for your version and maintain the same time and instructions for all candidates.
Where can I find the PDF or the answers to the Moss test?
We don't share them here: the material is usually copyrighted, and knowing the answers would invalidate the result. If you're in HR, request the test and its manual from a provider that can document its origin and rules. If you're a candidate, answer honestly.
Is it useful for selecting supervisors?
It can be a supplementary piece of information, but it's not enough to make a decision on its own, and current evidence doesn't support a cutoff point. A structured interview, a simulation, and tests with technical documentation provide a more solid foundation. For internal candidates, add the 360-degree evaluation and performance history.
If you're reviewing how you evaluate your future managers, at Hirint you can combine competency tests, soft skills and video interviews in the same process.