An emotional intelligence test measures how a person perceives, understands, and regulates their own and others' emotions. In the workplace, it's used for recruitment and development, but not all tests measure the same thing: some are aptitude tests with correct answers, while others are questionnaires where the person describes themselves. Knowing which type you're taking changes how you interpret the results.
Table of Contents
What is an emotional intelligence test and what does it measure?
The term was proposed by Peter Salovey and John Mayer in a article from 1990 as a set of skills: accurately assessing and expressing emotion in oneself and others, regulating it, and using feelings to plan and act. Later, Daniel Goleman brought the idea to the business world, and with its popularity came very different tools under the same label.
Therefore, an emotional intelligence test can measure:
- Capabilities: If the person solves problems with emotional content well, such as identifying the emotion on a face or predicting how a mood will change.
- Self-perception and traits: how the person is perceived in terms of their emotions, empathy, optimism, or stress management.
- Competencies observed: what others (boss, peers, collaborators) see in their behavior, in 360-degree formats.
The model's own authors acknowledge this division. an article in American Psychologist, Mayer, Salovey, and Caruso describe a schism between those who study emotional intelligence as a group of mental capacities and those who study a mixture of positive traits such as happiness, self-esteem, or optimism.
Ability, trait, and mixed models: how do they differ?
For HR, this is the fundamental decision. The model defines what a high score means and how easy it is to inflate it.
| Model | What do you understand by emotional intelligence? | Test format | Example of instrument | What to watch out for in selection |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capacity (Mayer and Salovey) | Skills for processing emotional information | Problems with better or worse answers | MSCEIT 2 | Relationship with unequal performance according to position |
| Trait (Petrides) | Self-perceived traits and abilities within personality | Self-report | TMMS-24 and other trait questionnaires | Overlap with personality and social desirability |
| Mixed (competitions) | A mix of skills, traits, and competencies | Self-report or third-party assessment | EQ-i 2.0 | Social desirability and breadth of the construct |
The trait approach was formulated by Petrides and Furnham, who in a 2001 study They define emotional intelligence as a constellation of self-perceived traits and abilities and conclude that it fits as a distinct factor within personality taxonomies. Therefore, a trait questionnaire is more like a personality test than an ability test, and it's best to read it in conjunction with what you already know about models like the ones we compared in [previous section/reference]. Big Five or DISC.
What emotional intelligence tests are used in the workplace?
These are the instruments that most frequently appear when HR seeks evidence with technical backing. The data comes from the publisher's information sheet or the publication itself.
| Test | Guy | Duration | Population | What delivers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MSCEIT 2 | Ability | 30 minutes | 18 years or older | Four domains and a total score |
| MSCEIT (previous version, 2002) | Ability | 30 to 45 minutes | 17 years or older | 141 items and 15 main scores |
| EQ-i 2.0 | Self-report, mixed model | 15 to 20 minutes | 18 years or older | 5 composite scales and 15 subscales |
| TMMS-24 | Self-report, trait | Brief | Validated with university students | Attention, clarity, and emotional repair |
Some details that matter when choosing:
- MSCEIT 2. Your editor, MHS, It is described as a performance-based test that asks test-takers to solve problems about emotional or interpersonal situations. It measures the ability to perceive, connect with, understand, and manage emotions, is administered and scored online, and requires a B level qualification. It is available in North American English and European Spanish.
- previous MSCEIT. According to the record of Consortium for Research on Emotional Intelligence in Organizations, It has 141 items and 15 main scores: one total, two area, four branch, and eight task. Its Spanish adaptation, published by TEA Ediciones, reported an overall reliability of 0.95, with 0.93 in the experiential area and 0.90 in the strategic area, in a sample of 2,060 people.
- EQ-i 2.0. MHS It indicates a duration of 15 to 20 minutes and five composite scales: self-perception, self-expression, interpersonal, decision-making, and stress management. Certification is required to use it.
- TMMS-24. It is the modified Spanish version of the Trait Meta-Mood Scale. its validation with 292 university students, The subscales exceeded 0.85 for internal consistency, and four-week stability ranged from 0.60 to 0.83. It measures Three factors: attention, clarity, and repair. It was born in research; for selection it is advisable to check if there are standards with working population.
What does the evidence say about its use in selection?
The evidence is useful, but less conclusive than the marketing of some tests suggests.
The meta-analysis of O'Boyle and colleagues (2011) The studies were classified into three streams: ability tests, self-reports based on the four-branch model, and mixed competency models. All three showed adjusted correlations between 0.24 and 0.30 with job performance, and the self-report streams (based on the four-branch and mixed models) provided the greatest incremental validity, surpassing cognitive ability and the Big Five personality factors.
The one from Joseph and Newman (2010) It adds a key nuance for HR: the relationship between emotional intelligence ability and performance was inconsistent. It positively predicted performance in emotionally demanding roles (e.g., those involving constant customer interaction) and negatively predicted performance in emotionally demanding roles. Mixed measures did explain performance beyond cognitive ability and personality.
What does this mean in practice?
- Emotional intelligence makes more sense as a criterion when the position requires genuine emotional work. In other positions, its weight should be less.
- A self-report can add information, but in a selection process, the candidate has reason to present themselves well. Ask the editor what consistency or social desirability indicators they include.
- Some of what a trait questionnaire measures is already covered by a good personality test. If you're already using one, check if the second one offers anything new.
How to choose an emotional intelligence test for selection in Mexico?
Before hiring a proofreader, review these points with the editor or provider. These are the same questions you should ask any proofreader. psychometric workplace test.
- Model. Does it measure ability, trait, or skills? The information sheet should clearly state this.
- Evidence with workers. Are there validity studies with job performance, not just with students or well-being?
- Reliability. Ask for the coefficients by scale, not just the total.
- Rules. What population is your candidate being compared to? If the benchmark is from Spain or the United States, ask if there are standards for Mexico and how they were developed.
- Language and adaptation. A translation is not an adaptation. guidelines of the International Test Commission They ask to verify that the test is appropriate for the group being evaluated.
- Who can apply it. Some require a level of user qualification or certification, such as level B of the MSCEIT 2.
- Personal data. Inform the candidate of the purpose, request their consent, and process the results accordingly. Federal Law on the Protection of Personal Data Held by Private Parties and the applicable regulations. For specific questions, consult your legal department.
Be wary of free online tests that give an "emotional intelligence percentage" in three minutes. They can be useful for personal reflection, but they lack standards and evidence to make judgments about a person.
How to interpret and apply the results?
The result is input for the conversation, not a verdict. This order helps to use it well:
- Define what emotional behaviors the position requires. For example, calming an upset customer or giving difficult feedback. Part of the job profile.
- Compare with the instrument's norms, not with the average of your last process.
- Read the scales, not just the total. A person can perceive emotions well and still have difficulty managing them.
- Turn the low points into behavioral interview questions. If managing emotions scores low, ask for a recent example of a conflict and how you resolved it.
- Integrate with the CV, interview, and other tests. The decision is made by one person using multiple sources.
- In development, use it as a starting point. The results can feed a individual development plan with observable objectives.
When what you need is not a broad construct but specific interpersonal skills for the job, such as communication or teamwork, you can assess them directly with a soft skills test and compare them in the interview. That's the approach Hirint uses.
Common mistakes when using an emotional intelligence test
- Use it as the sole filter. No score justifies dismissing someone without further evidence.
- Mixing models when comparing. A capability score and a self-report score are not interchangeable.
- Apply it equally to all positions. Evidence suggests that its value depends on the emotional burden of the job.
- Ignoring social desirability. In a self-assessment for selection, a very high score may reflect how the candidate wants to present themselves.
- Using tests without standards or technical specifications. If the supplier cannot explain how it was built, do not use it to make a decision.
- Not informing the person being evaluated. The candidate needs to know what is being measured, why, and who will see their data.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does an emotional intelligence test last?
It depends on the instrument. According to its publisher, the MSCEIT 2 takes about 30 minutes, and the EQ-i 2.0 takes between 15 and 20 minutes. The previous version of the MSCEIT took 30 to 45 minutes. When planning a selection process, add the time of the other tests together to avoid excessively lengthening the candidate's experience.
What are the 4 pillars of emotional intelligence?
In the Mayer and Salovey model of ability, which forms the basis of the MSCEIT 2, the key skills are perceiving emotions, using them or connecting them to thought, understanding them, and managing them. Other models, such as the one popularized by Goleman, focus on self-awareness, self-regulation, empathy, and social skills. Before comparing results, confirm which model each test uses.
What does the TMMS-24 test measure?
It is a brief self-report questionnaire, the Spanish version of the Trait Meta-Mood Scale, which measures three factors of perceived emotional intelligence: attention to emotions, clarity in understanding them, and mood repair. It has good reliability in studies with university students, but it measures how the person sees themselves, not their demonstrated ability.
Which emotional intelligence test is best for selection?
There isn't one best approach for every situation. It depends on the position, the model you're interested in, and the evidence available for your target population. Ability tests are harder to fake; self-reports are faster. In both cases, ask for reliability, standards, and studies on job performance, and use them to complement your CV and interview.
Can an emotional intelligence test replace an interview?
No. The test provides comparable data, but it doesn't replace the interview or the analysis of the candidate's career path. Its best use is to guide the interview: the results indicate what to explore with questions about real-life situations. The final decision is made by a person, with the candidate's informed consent and in accordance with applicable regulations.
If you want to organize which soft skills to measure for each position and how to combine them with the interview, at Hirint we can review it with you.