The Zavic test is a questionnaire with 20 situations in which the person ranks four response options to reveal their values (morality, legality, indifference, and corruption) and their interests (economic, political, social, and religious). In Mexico, it is used in the selection process for operational positions, especially where honesty is a concern. Its origin is undocumented. the only thesis from UNAM that we found on its use Its reliability was not calculated, so it should be treated as supplementary data and not as a filter.
Table of Contents
What is the Zavic test and what does it measure?
It is a paper-and-pencil questionnaire, for individual or group application, which the thesis of Gabriela Uribe and Ramón Ortega (UNAM, FES Iztacala, 2007) describes based on a 2004 manual from the Society of Applied Psychology. According to that description, it seeks to identify trends in eight aspects: four of values and four of interests.
The table summarizes what each scale is intended to measure according to the manual and what should be taken into account when reading it.
| Block | Scale | What does it intend to measure? | What to keep in mind |
|---|---|---|---|
| Values | Moral | Follow the rules of good behavior | Almost all candidates score high |
| Values | Legality | Desire for honesty and adherence to policies | It is the scale that is most looked at in selection |
| Values | Indifference | Lack of commitment to work | A high score does not prove a lack of interest |
| Values | Corruption | Tendency towards bribery | A high score does not mean that the person has committed dishonest acts. |
| Interests | Economic | Interest in profits and returns | It depends on the position; high or low is better. |
| Interests | Political | Interest in power and advancement | It might be a good fit for sales or management roles, but not for a support role. |
| Interests | Social | Concern for people | Useful for customer service, but not very informative if everyone gets a high score |
| Interests | Religious | Respect for authority, order, and rules | It does not measure religious beliefs, even though the name suggests it. |
The names of the interest categories are reminiscent of Edward Spranger's typology of values, the same one that gave rise to Allport's Study of Values. We were unable to locate a document that formally links both tests, so it is not advisable to transfer the evidence from the other to the Zavic test.
An important distinction: the manual refers to "job values." The correct interpretation is not whether a person has good or bad values, but whether their profile matches the requirements of the position. This necessitates defining the desired profile beforehand.
Where did the Zavic test come from?
Its origin is unclear. The authors of the 2007 thesis approached the Society of Applied Psychology to obtain the instrument and write that, as is the case with hundreds of published tests, It was not possible to locate its origins. Some online sources attribute it to José de Jesús Zavala and César Corsi, but we found no manual, article, or record to confirm this.
For HR, this is already useful information. A test without an identifiable author also typically lacks a technical manual with data on reliability, validity, and standards. guidelines of the International Test Commission They ask to verify that the technical documentation of a test is sufficient before using it.
How is it applied and graded?
The version described in the thesis is answered in about 20 minutes, with no fixed time limit. Broadly speaking, the process follows these steps:
- Instructions. It is explained that there are no right or wrong answers and that in each situation you have to order the four options, from the most convincing (4) to the least convincing (1), without repeating numbers.
- Guided example. The applicator observes the first exercise to check that the person understood the instruction, without guiding them on what to answer.
- Answer. The person answers all the questions, alone and without interruptions.
- Record. The responses are transferred to a results sheet and totaled by column, one per scale.
- Reading. Each scale is classified as high (21 to 40) or low (1 to 20) and compared to the job profile.
We do not reproduce situations, answer sheets, or answer keys here. The material is copyrighted, and if candidates are aware of it beforehand, the result no longer reveals anything about them.
What does the evidence say about the Zavic test?
Very little. In open repositories we only found the 2007 undergraduate thesis, which is not a psychometric study: it describes the incorporation of the test in a company in the pharmaceutical sector with branches in Mexico City, Monterrey and Guadalajara.
| What the study did | What he found | What doesn't answer |
|---|---|---|
| He administered the test to 715 candidates for operational positions. | The annual turnover decreased from 38.78 % to 27.13 % after including it | Whether the improvement is due to the test or to other changes in the same year |
| He rejected applicants with unauthorized scale combinations | 33.28% of applicants were eliminated by this filter. | If those candidates had performed worse |
| He reviewed the distribution of each scale | The 94.7 % scored high in morality and the 92.8 % scored high in legality | Reliability, validity, or standards of the instrument |
Source of all figures: Uribe and Ortega, UNAM, 2007.
Three points to keep in mind to avoid over-reading:
- It's a before and after for a single company, without a comparison group. The authors themselves link some changes from the same year to closer supervision, so the drop in turnover cannot be attributed solely to the test.
- No reliability or validity indices were calculated. The thesis does not report internal consistency, stability, or a relationship with performance measured by an independent criterion.
- The authors urge caution. They write that the isolated result of a test should not be considered definitive and that, for managers or middle managers, another instrument may be required.
A cautious interpretation: there is no published evidence to support hiring decisions based on the Zavic index. Nor has it been proven that it offers no benefit, because no one has studied it with the necessary rigor.
What are the limitations of the Zavic test in selection?
Beyond the lack of studies, the format itself has limitations that should be known before using it.
The scores depend on each other. Since the same points are always distributed in each situation (4, 3, 2, and 1), the total is fixed. If one scale goes up, another must go down. Data of this type are called ipsative, and Adam Meade analyzed in 2004 the problems that arise in selectionWith the same individuals, ipsative measures and regulations led to very different selection decisions. In practice, the Zavic indicates what a person prioritizes in relation to themselves, and comparing them to another person is much more complex.
The cut-off is not a benchmark. Classifying each scale as high or low based on the midpoint of the range is not equivalent to comparing it to a normative group. In the thesis sample, 43.5% of the candidates scored "high" on corruption. And at the same time, the 94.7 % scored high in morale. Interpreting either of these data points as a personal trait would be a mistake.
Social desirability matters. The options describe socially valued or disapproved behaviors, and a candidate knows which one to choose. The fact that almost everyone scores high in moral, legal, and social aspects points in that direction: a scale on which almost everyone scores the same makes little distinction.
Names can lead to mistakes. «"Religious" doesn't measure beliefs, and "corruption" doesn't measure past conduct. A report stating "candidate with a tendency toward corruption" can damage a person without any basis. Furthermore, the Federal Labor Law Article 133 prohibits refusing to hire on the grounds of religion or opinions, and law on the protection of personal data held by private individuals Data revealing religious, philosophical, and moral beliefs is considered sensitive, and processing requires explicit written consent. How a values test fits within these rules is something your legal department should review; this text is not legal advice.
If your company already uses the Zavic test, what should you review?
Removing it abruptly isn't always feasible. These steps help you decide based on data:
- Ask for the documentation. Author, version, year of the manual, and, if available, reliability data and standards. If the supplier can't provide this information, you already have an answer.
- Remove automatic rejections. No candidate should be excluded solely based on a combination of scales.
- Review the language of the reports. Replace labels like "highly corrupt" with a description of what the test collects: stated preferences in hypothetical situations.
- Analyze your own data. With the support of a psychometrics specialist, see how the scales are distributed among your candidates and whether any are related to retention or performance.
- Compare with other sources. A structured interview, references, and a test with technical documentation should carry more weight than this result.
- Take care of the consent. Explain what the test is used for, who will see the results, and how long they are stored, according to applicable regulations.
What alternatives can be used to evaluate values and integrity?
If you're looking to find out if a person fits your company's way of working or to reduce the risk of counterproductive behavior, there are more reliable options.
| Need | Alternative | What does it contribute? |
|---|---|---|
| Honesty and compliance with rules | Integrity test with technical documentation | A meta-analysis by Van Iddekinge and colleagues studied its relationship with counterproductive behaviors |
| Culture fit | Structured interview about real situations and explicit cultural fit criteria | Avoid confusing personal affinity with job fit |
| Your organization's values | A questionnaire built on the values that your company defines | Measure what you need, not eight generic scales |
| Conduct in the workplace | Simulation or case study | It shows what the person does, not just what they say. |
In it Sackett and colleagues' 2022 meta-analysis, The structured interview obtained one of the highest validity estimates for predicting performance (0.42). This is a good foundation on which to add further evidence.
If you want to measure the fit with values that your company defines, the Hirint values test Part of that set of values is used to provide a measure of each person's fit. To organize the rest of the battery, review how to choose psychometric tests for work.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the Zavic test measure?
According to the manual described in a 2007 UNAM thesis, it measures four values (morality, legality, indifference, and corruption) and four interests (economic, political, social, and religious) based on 20 situations in which the person ranks four options. It collects declared preferences in hypothetical cases, not real-life behaviors, and has no published validity studies.
How long does the Zavic test last?
The version described in the UNAM thesis takes about 20 minutes to complete, although it doesn't specify a time limit. It's advisable to follow the manual for your version and maintain the same instructions and conditions for all candidates so that the results are comparable.
Who created the Zavic test?
It is not documented. The authors of the 2007 thesis obtained the manual from the Society of Applied Psychology and state that it was not possible to trace its origins. Some online entries attribute it to José de Jesús Zavala and César Corsi, but we found no publication to confirm this.
Is the Zavic test useful for determining if a candidate is honest?
Not with certainty. Legality and corruption scales reflect how a person ranks options in written situations, and it's easy to choose the socially desirable response. Without valid data, no result should be used to label someone as dishonest. For that purpose, there are integrity tests with more supporting research.
How are the results of the Zavic test interpreted?
Each score is totaled and classified as high or low, and the profile is compared to the job requirements. Because the points are distributed across the scales, a high score forces another to fall, making comparing candidates tricky. It should be used as a guide for the interview, never as the sole criterion.
If you're reviewing how you assess values in your selection process, at Hirint you can combine a values test, soft skills and interviews in the same process.