The Draw-a-Person test is a projective technique in which a person draws a human figure, and a psychologist interprets the drawing to formulate hypotheses about their personality. In personnel selection, it can provide topics to explore in the interview, but the evidence regarding its validity is limited and does not justify basing a hiring decision on it.
If your company in Mexico uses it through a supplier or you receive it in a report, this guide explains what it is, what the research says, and what to ask.
Table of Contents
What is the human figure drawing test?
This name refers to two different uses of the same drawing, and it is best not to confuse them:
- Projective use. This is the version associated with Karen Machover, the one that usually appears in adult assessments. It's based on the idea that the way a person draws reflects aspects of their self-image and personality.
- Use as a measure of intellectual development. Another tradition, originating with Florence Goodenough, scores children's drawings based on the details they include to estimate cognitive development. A current system along these lines is the DAP:QSS, designed for children.
When a selection report mentions the "human figure drawing test," it almost always refers to its projective use. It belongs to the same family of techniques as the Wartegg test or the Lüscher test, with the same interpretation challenges.
How is it applied and what does the psychologist record?
The application appears simple: the person receives a sheet of paper and a pencil and is asked to draw a human figure. Depending on the version, the psychologist may ask for a second figure or ask questions about the drawing upon completion. In addition to the final result, they typically observe how the person works during the task.
We do not reproduce here the complete instructions, interpretation criteria, or examples of "answers." Psychologist's Code of Ethics The Mexican Society of Psychology requests that the content, answers, or possible results of the tests not be disclosed to those who are not psychologists (article 27). Furthermore, knowing them beforehand alters what the technique aims to observe.
Within an evaluation for a position, a reasonable order would be this:
- Define which job competencies you want to evaluate and with what evidence.
- Decide with the responsible psychologist whether a projective technique provides something that other tests do not.
- Inform the candidate of the purpose, the use of the results and who will see them, and ask for their consent.
- Apply and interpret with an identified system, and leave it in writing in the report.
- Compare the hypotheses with the interview, the trajectory, and other evidence.
What does it intend to measure and what cannot it measure?
In its projective use, it is interpreted as an expression of body image, self-concept, and the way one relates to the environment. These are broad constructs, and the technique addresses them from the interpreter's hypotheses, not from a scoring system with rules.
What it doesn't measure is just as important to HR:
- It does not measure specific job skills, such as negotiation, planning, or customer service.
- It's not an intelligence test for adults. For that, there are standardized aptitude tests, like the ones we explain in the Raven's test.
- It does not allow you to know if someone is lying or if they will be honest in the position.
- It is not useful for diagnosing anyone in a selection process, which is not a clinical context.
What does the scientific evidence say?
The research suggests caution. These are the most useful facts for making a decision:
- General review. The review of Lilienfeld, Wood and Garb (2000) Regarding projective techniques, it concludes that the validity evidence for human figure drawings is even more limited than that of the Rorschach or the TAT, and that, with few exceptions, these techniques have not consistently shown incremental validity on other psychometric data.
- A study with applicants. In a study published in the journal Telos (2012), In a study of 559 applicants aged 17 to 47 for university admission in Venezuela, split-half reliability was 0.77 and inter-rater agreement was 0.87. Internal consistency was 0.51, which the authors interpret as indicating weak correlation between the aspects measured by the test. The authors conclude that the test is suitable for use with local norms, but the study does not correlate the results with subsequent performance.
- As a measure of children's intelligence. In a study with 2,543 children, The quantitative DAP:QSS system showed low correlations with Raven's Matrices (from 0.156 to 0.498), a sensitivity of 0.12, and false negative rates of 87.9% and false positive rates of 82%. The authors conclude that it did not provide a robust psychometric assessment of intellectual functioning.
In short: two evaluators agreeing on how to code a drawing doesn't prove that the interpretation predicts how someone will work. For a hiring decision, that second piece of evidence is what's missing.
Can it be used for personnel selection in Mexico?
Its use is not prohibited, but there are conditions that should be known before requesting or accepting it in a report.
Who applies and interprets it. The Code of Ethics of the Mexican Society of Psychology expressly includes personnel selection among the purposes of psychological evaluation (article 15) and asks the psychologist to:
- ensure that the techniques you use are based on sound data regarding reliability, validity and standards (Article 17);
- not to use instruments that are only translated or with data obtained from populations other than the one being evaluated (Article 18);
- not to promote the use of assessment techniques by untrained persons (Article 21).
Therefore, HR should not interpret these drawings using guides downloaded from the internet. Their role is to ask the responsible psychologist good questions.
Personal data. If the report includes conclusions about the candidate's emotional state or health, it may constitute sensitive personal data according to the Federal Law on the Protection of Personal Data Held by Private Parties, which requires their express written consent (Article 8). Review the case with your legal department: this is not legal advice.
Before accepting a report with a human figure, ask for answers to these questions:
- Which psychologist applied and interpreted it, and what training did they have in the technique?
- What interpretation system was used?
- Which job behavior is related to each finding?
- Are there any regulations for the adult Mexican population?
- Does any other independent source support the same conclusion?
What can be used to complement or replace it?
If the goal is to predict performance, there are methods with more direct evidence. The table uses the mean validity estimates of Sackett and colleagues (2022), who reviewed previous meta-analyses of selection. That review does not include the human figure test, and that is why it appears without a score.
| Method | Estimated average validity | When does it help? |
|---|---|---|
| Structured interview | 0.42 | Almost always, with the same questions and guidelines for everyone. |
| Job knowledge test | 0.40 | Positions that require technical knowledge from day one |
| Work sample | 0.33 | Observable and easy-to-simulate tasks |
| Cognitive ability test | 0.31 | Positions requiring quick learning or problem-solving skills |
| Unstructured interview | 0.19 | It's advisable to structure it before using it to decide. |
| Human Figure Drawing Test | No estimate in this review | As a source of hypotheses, under the responsibility of a psychologist |
These figures are averages that vary depending on the position, so they're useful for ranking options, not for making a single choice. If you want to see how to combine several tests in one process, check out our guide on psychometric assessment.
When you need comparable results across candidates, Hirint offers Psychometric and technical tests for MexicoCognitive, personality, DISC, soft skills, languages and knowledge, which complement the CV and the interview.
When does it make sense to use it?
It may be appropriate when a psychologist with specific training uses it as an additional source of hypotheses, in processes with few candidates and time to verify what was observed in the interview.
It doesn't seem like a good option in large-scale recruitment processes, when there isn't a trained professional in charge, or when the result is used to eliminate candidates on its own. In those cases, the decision would be based on a reading that's difficult to review and explain to the person being evaluated. The final decision is human and must be justifiable based on the job requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Machover Draw-a-Person test?
It is the projective version of the Draw-a-Person test associated with Karen Machover. The person draws a figure, and a psychologist interprets the drawing to formulate hypotheses about their self-image and personality. The interpretation depends on the evaluator's system and experience, and evidence for its validity is limited.
Does the Draw-a-Person test measure intelligence?
In adults, no. There is a tradition of scoring details in children's drawings to estimate cognitive development, but a study of 2,543 children found that the DAP:QSS system did not provide a robust measure of intellectual functioning. Specific tests with norms and performance evidence exist for assessing cognitive ability in selection processes.
Can the human figure drawing test be used in personnel selection?
It can be used as a source of hypotheses, applied and interpreted by a psychologist, but never as the sole criterion for hiring or dismissal. Research has not shown that it predicts job performance. In Mexico, the Code of Ethics of the Mexican Society of Psychology requires that assessments be based on techniques with reliability, validity, and appropriate standards.
What is the difference between a projective technique and a psychometric test?
A psychometric test presents standardized questions or tasks, is scored using fixed rules, and compares the result to population norms. A projective technique uses open-ended stimuli, such as a drawing, and its interpretation depends more on the evaluator. This is why it is more difficult to demonstrate that two psychologists can reach the same conclusion and that this conclusion is predictive of something.
Are the interpretations of the test in PDF or online format useful?
Not for evaluating anyone. A manual or a downloaded list of meanings is no substitute for a psychologist's training or established standards, and applying such lists to a candidate can lead to unfounded conclusions. If you are a candidate, there are no right answers to prepare: the helpful thing to do is ask what the test will be used for and how your data will be handled.
Do you want an assessment with comparable results between candidates? At Hirint, we can review with you which tests are best suited for each position.