Until a few years ago, the Hiring processes were characterized by being quite subjectiveAlthough the goal has always been to find the ideal candidate to fill a position, this search was based on tests such as personal interviews, where the recruiter's subjective biases ended up being decisive when making the decision of whether or not a person should continue within the selection process.
What we have seen in recent years is that recruiters' biases end up reducing the effectiveness of selection processes. Often, They do not lead to the selection of the most suitable candidate, and this ends up being expensive for the company, which must face the costs associated with the rotation and the launching of a new search for candidates.
Fortunately, this is changing thanks to tools such as psychometric tests. Through them we can obtain objective information about a person's abilities and skills. Information that is easily compared with the results of other candidates and allows us to evaluate which one best fits the profile sought.
Why are subjective biases not a positive thing in selection?
To fill a vacancy, you must ensure that the profile of the chosen candidate fits within the hard and soft skills that have been collected in the Description of the jobFor example, for a programming position we need a person who has training and experience in this field, but we also need someone who is able to work under pressure and has a talent for problem solving.
But even in cases where a person has the right hard and soft skills for a position, it may be that they are not the best fit for it. This happens if there is not a good fit between that individual's personal values and the culture of the organization.
If we do not achieve this fit, it will not be long before the employment relationship breaks down. This will lead to the launch of a new selection process and the company will have to assume this cost and all those associated with integrating a new member into the workforce (training, low productivity during the first few weeks due to the need to adapt to the company and the position, etc.).
Obtaining all the information necessary to ensure successful hiring is a complex and lengthy process. However, technology is currently the best ally to achieve this. It is not only capable of analyzing information quickly, but it is also responsible for doing so objectively, eliminating the subjective bias of recruiters.
Why is this seen as such a negative thing? Because when it operates it ends up giving rise to hiring unsuitable people, either because they do not have the skills that are necessary for the position or because they do not fit well with the organizational culture.
How do biases affect the selection process?
Experience shows us that biases can operate in different ways and have a significant impact on the selection process:
- Elimination of qualified candidates. If the candidate does not fit the recruiter's preconceived stereotype of the ideal profile for the position, he or she may end up being discarded even if he or she is actually well qualified.
- Discrimination. Even if it is unconscious, the application of certain biases ends up causing discrimination against certain groups such as women, young people, people over 50 or foreigners. This limits diversity within the organization and reduces its competitiveness.
- Reduction of diversity of thought. Creating teams that are too homogeneous leads to problems when it comes to tackling complex problems and generating innovative ideas.
- Increased staff turnover. If the candidate chosen based on subjective criteria turns out not to be the most suitable (which is usually the case), the employment relationship is likely to break down sooner rather than later.
- Damage to the company's reputation. In an environment where there is great competition to attract and retain talent, applying purely subjective selection methods negatively affects the the company's reputation as an employer.
The future of people and organizations are Skills.
Will you join us?
Practical examples of how biases affect recruitment
There are many subjective biases that can be applied by recruiters, but the most common ones are the following:
affinity bias
It plays in favor of certain candidates, who are favored by share interests or life experiences similar to those of the recruiter. For example, having gone to the same university or being a big football fan.
Beauty bias
It's not that recruiters are superficial people, but all experts agree that the beauty bias is very present in the selection processes. Especially in those positions that imply a direct interaction with the company's customers.
In this way, candidates who are considered more attractive have a greater chance of being selected, to the detriment of other candidates who are less physically attractive but do have the skills required to successfully fill the position offered.
Confirmation bias
If job interviews are not well structured, the recruiter ends up actively searching information that confirms preconceived beliefs that you already have on the candidate.
Acting this way leads you to ignore or minimize all evidence that contradicts those beliefs.
stereotype bias
Although it is becoming less common, there are still recruiters who unconsciously apply biases based on gender, race or age stereotypes.
For example, assuming that a woman is not suitable for a technical leadership position or that a candidate over 50 will not be willing to learn new skills.
Featured cases
Biases are not something that only affects small companies, not at all. Large companies have also applied and continue to apply them when making their hiring decisions.
In the case of the all-powerful technology industry Silicon Valley, is well known for its tendency to over-represent white men who have studied at prestigious universities within its staff. This limits the opportunities for all those who do not fit into that mould.
The financial sector has also been criticized for its lack of diversity. To this day, women and minorities remain underrepresented in corporate leadership positions. major Wall Street firms.
In the case of large retail chains, criticism focuses on racial discrimination, because there is evidence that candidates who belong to ethnic minorities are less likely to be hired or promoted within the company.
Is technology the solution to bias in the selection process?
The answer is “yes”, but this is something that needs to be qualified. The technology that is currently applied in selection processes, such as Artificial Intelligence (AI) that is responsible for screening CVs, can be of great help when it comes to obtaining objective data that is easy to compare.
However, we must bear in mind that Even technology can fall into subjective biases. Because it is fed with information that we humans provide. Therefore, if the The data it is fed with is biased, it is more than likely that it will end up perpetuating certain biases even further.
Let's say we use a selection algorithm in our company that we have fed with the historical hiring data of the business over the last ten years. If it turns out that in that time we have hired mostly men for certain roles, our technological tool will end up immediately discarding women for those positions when it starts doing its job.
Sometimes the problem is in the job descriptions. If we have not updated them and they include biased language that excludes certain groups, those who were not taken into account when creating the job description will automatically be left out of the process.
Although it may seem unbelievable, there have been cases of chatbots that are perpetuating gender stereotypes by responding differently to questions asked with male or female names. And it is known that facial recognition systems are less accurate when identifying African-American people, which leads to algorithmic discrimination in selection processes.
To prevent this from happening, it is important Select the information that feeds the technology very carefully which helps us in selection, and promote diversity also within the development teams of these tools. In addition, it is essential to regularly audit the algorithm to identify and eliminate biases.
Only with constant work on training recruiters and improving the digital tools they use in their work will we be able to ensure that subjective biases in selection become a thing of the past.