Performance indicators are measures that show how well an individual or team performs compared to the expectations of their role. They can be numerical, such as the percentage of on-time deliveries, or observable behaviors that are evaluated using agreed-upon criteria. When well-defined, they provide a clear picture of the individual's or team's performance. performance evaluation concrete evidence to discuss and decide, although the decision remains with the people.
This guide focuses on measuring the work of employees, not on the numbers of the HR area as a function.
Table of Contents
What are performance indicators?
An indicator answers a simple question: how will we know that this work was done well? manual for measuring OPM performance, The Office of Personnel Management (OPM), the U.S. federal government's personnel department, compiles four general metrics typically applied to employees and work units: quality, quantity, timeliness, and cost-effectiveness. Even if your company operates differently, this list helps identify areas for improvement. A position measured solely by volume, for example, overlooks whether the work was actually completed well.
It is useful to separate four terms that are often mixed up:
| Term | What is | Example in customer service |
|---|---|---|
| Indicator | What is measured | Resolution on first contact |
| Formula or evidence | How is it calculated or verified? | Cases resolved on first contact / cases handled × 100 |
| Goal | The value expected to be achieved | The agreed percentage for the quarter |
| Threshold | The level from which action must be taken | The percentage that triggers a review with the leader |
What about KPIs? A KPI is an indicator that the company has chosen because of its importance to a key objective. Every KPI is an indicator, but not every indicator deserves that label.
Performance is not limited to tasks. IWPQ questionnaire manual, Linda Koopmans' model distinguishes three dimensions: task performance, contextual performance (cooperating, communicating, facilitating the work of others), and counterproductive behaviors. A form that only records output leaves out the person who supports the team.
What types of performance indicators exist?
The most useful classification for evaluating people is based on the level at which they are measured. Within each level, the outcome or behavior can also be measured.
Individual indicators
They measure what depends on each employee: their deliverables, their quality, their deadlines. They form the basis of individual conversations, provided the person truly controls what is being measured. If a deadline depends on another department, the data describes the process rather than the person responsible for it.
Team indicators
They measure a shared outcome, such as project completion. The OPM manual distinguishes between group performance, measured in aggregate, and the contribution of each individual, measured individually. Its rules are for the United States government, but the criteria can be applied in any organization: the team's result informs, and each member's assessment also requires its own evidence. The leader who has the resources to achieve that result can be held accountable for it. CIPD, The British Institute of HR Professionals adds that in positions highly dependent on teamwork, it may be more effective to set objectives based on behaviors.
Indicators by position
These are common to those who hold the same position, for example, all account executives. They are derived from the job description and its competency matrix, and allow for comparison using the same criteria. For the comparison to be fair, it's necessary to check if the conditions are similar: a more challenging portfolio or area changes what the number means.
Outcome and behavior indicators
The CIPD It points out that performance can be assessed by its results or by the way the work was done. The former are usually easier to quantify in positions with visible output. In knowledge work, results are more difficult to attribute, and an assessment of behaviors using instruments whose reliability has been proven is usually necessary.
Examples of performance indicators by area
The table provides examples for adaptation, not a list to copy. Each company sets its own goals based on its own data.
| Area or position | Outcome indicator | Behavioral indicator | Revision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | Closed sales / period quota × 100 | Complete registration and opportunity time in the CRM | Monthly |
| Customer service | Cases resolved on first contact / cases handled × 100 | Quality of interaction, according to a rubric applied to a sample | Monthly |
| Production | Units without defects / units produced × 100 | Adherence to safety procedures, verified in audits | Monthly |
| Logistics | On-time deliveries / scheduled deliveries × 100 | Early notification of incidents to the internal client | Monthly |
| Finance | Closings delivered on time / closings in the period × 100 | Documentation of criteria so that another person can review them | Monthly |
| Marketing | Qualified prospects / period target × 100 | Clarity of campaign summaries, valued by sales | Quarterly |
| Recruitment | Vacancies filled within the agreed timeframe / vacancies assigned × 100 | Response to candidates within the defined timeframe | Monthly |
| Technology | On-time deliveries / committed deliveries × 100 | Usefulness of their code reviews, according to their peers | Per work cycle |
| Administration | Processes without rework / processes managed × 100 | Responding to internal requests according to a simple rubric | Quarterly |
| Leadership | Team objectives achieved / agreed objectives × 100 | Follow-up conversations held and outcome in the 360-degree evaluation | Quarterly |
The behavior indicator prevents rewarding those who meet their quota at the expense of their colleagues or CRM data.
How to define performance indicators step by step?
These steps adapt the logic of OPM manual to a private company. They work best if the leader and the employee go through them together.
- Part of the position and the objective of the period. Ask what that position needs to achieve this year and what area objective it contributes to.
- Write about achievements, not activities. The OPM recommends describing them with nouns and not with verbs: "error-free closing reports" says more than "review reports".
- Choose the general size. Decide what matters in that achievement: quality, quantity, timeliness, cost, or a combination.
- Write the formula or the evidence. If it can be counted, note the unit. If it can only be described, the OPM asks for clarification on who is judging it and what factors are considered.
- Check control and data source. Confirm that the person influences the outcome and that the data exists without disproportionate extra work.
- Set baseline, target, and threshold. Check the recent periods before setting a number. A goal with no history is usually a gamble.
- Put it through a final filter. According to the OPM, elements and standards must be measurable, understandable, verifiable, equitable, and achievable. If any of these fail, rewrite them before communicating them.
A completed card might look like this:
| Field | Example: customer service executive |
|---|---|
| Aim | Resolve more cases without the customer having to call back. |
| Indicator | Resolution on first contact |
| Formula | Cases resolved on first contact / cases handled × 100 |
| Font | Ticketing system |
| Frequency | Monthly review, quarterly closing |
| Goal and threshold | They are agreed with the baseline of the last periods |
| Context | Cases requiring another area are excluded. |
| Responsible | Customer Service Leader |
How many indicators per person?
There is no set number. As a reference, the OPM manual states that, according to most experts, between three and seven critical elements are adequate for most work situations. With many more, no one remembers which ones matter.
How to use indicators in performance evaluation?
An indicator is most effective when it is known from the beginning of the period and reviewed before the end. This order is useful:
- At the beginning: records indicators, goals and weights in the performance evaluation format, and confirms that the collaborator understands them.
- During the period: Review progress regularly. The OPM points out that continuous monitoring allows for the detection of problems and the provision of support without waiting until the end, as well as the correction of unrealistic standards.
- At closing time: Read the results in conjunction with the behaviors and the context. A portfolio change, a staff departure, or a delay in another area could explain the data.
- After: It transforms reading into agreements for recognition, training, or goal setting.
When the indicator drops, the reason why remains a mystery. competency tests A 360-degree evaluation, one of the tools Hirint offers, can help explore whether there's a skills gap. Keep in mind that a test measures skills or traits at a given moment, not what the person achieved in their role, so it complements the indicator, not replaces it.
What mistakes should be avoided?
- Measure what the position does not control. The indicator ends up judging the luck or work of another area.
- Make the goal the only thing that matters. The CIPD He warns that numerical goals, by themselves, can become counterproductive if too much emphasis is placed on them.
- Stick to what's easy to talk about. What is abundant in the system is not always what matters in the job.
- Judging behaviors without criteria. Without a rubric with examples, each leader applies their own standard.
- Changing the rules mid-race. If an indicator ceases to make sense, it is adjusted and communicated, without being applied retroactively.
- Using personal data without notice. If an indicator feeds into bonuses, penalties, or dismissals, or relies on monitoring data, inform the employees and review it with your legal department in accordance with applicable regulations.
If you want to see how to turn these indicators into conversations and follow-up actions, in Hirint Performance We can show you with a case from your company.
If you also measure the HR function, consult Human resources KPIs by area. And to compare the numbers with the team's perception, a 180-degree evaluation can complement them.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a performance indicator and a KPI?
Performance indicator is the broad term: any measure that shows how well a job is going. A KPI is a specific indicator chosen for its importance to a key objective, which is why there are usually fewer of them. In practice, many companies use both terms interchangeably. What avoids confusion is documenting the formula, source, responsible party, and frequency, regardless of the terminology used.
How to measure performance in positions without clear metrics?
Describe the behaviors that distinguish a job well done and define who values them. OPM It suggests identifying the person making the judgment and the factors they focus on. A rubric with examples at each level, along with feedback from internal clients or a 360-degree evaluation, provides a more consistent basis than the general impression of a single leader.
How often should performance indicators be reviewed?
It depends on the pace of the job. Things that change weekly, like customer service, can be reviewed monthly; a long-term project is best reviewed by milestones. Whatever the frequency, the review must be timely to allow for course correction. An annual review without intermediate follow-up usually leaves little room to act on the issues identified.
Can soft skills be measured with performance indicators?
Yes, provided they translate into observable behaviors. "Good communication" cannot be verified; "notifies others of a delay before the agreed-upon date" can. Evaluations from leaders and colleagues provide this evidence, and it's advisable that the criteria be consistent across the board. A soft skills assessment can guide development, but it doesn't, on its own, demonstrate how someone behaves in their role.
Should performance indicators be linked to bonuses?
They can be linked, although it's best to do so carefully. When money is involved, the pressure to meet the quota increases, sometimes at the expense of quality or teamwork. Combining results and behaviors, separating development conversations from compensation discussions, and reviewing the scheme with your legal department helps reduce these unwanted effects.