An asynchronous video interview is a pre-recorded interview: the candidate answers questions prepared by the company in advance, at a time that suits them best, and the selection team reviews the answers afterward. It's useful for a comparable initial screening without scheduling conflicts. Platforms such as Hirint allows you to create video interviews in three steps: set up the questions and answers, add a tutorial for the candidate, and then evaluate each answer.
Table of Contents
What is an asynchronous video interview?
When we think of a video interview, we imagine two people talking live on Zoom, Teams, or Google Meet. The asynchronous video interview (also called asynchronous or one-way) breaks that idea: there is no one on the other side in real time.
The usual procedure is as follows:
- Configuration. The selection team defines the questions, the time to read each one, the response limit, and whether repeating the recording is allowed.
- Invitation. The candidate receives a link and a deadline to complete it.
- Recording. Read or listen to each question and record your answer from your computer or mobile phone.
- Assessment. One or more people from the team review the answers using the same criteria and decide who moves on to the next phase.
Compared to a live interview, the key difference is standardization: everyone receives the same questions, in the same order, and under the same conditions.
What are asynchronous video interviews used for?
When well-designed, they contribute five things to a selection process:
- A richer initial filtering than the CV. They allow you to see how the person expresses themselves, how they structure their ideas, and what examples they give, something that a cover letter does not show.
- A standardized assessment. In a one-on-one interview, the conversation tends to shift to different topics with each person. Here, everyone responds to the same questions, which makes it easier to compare profiles and reduces bias.
- Flexibility and access. Profiles that would otherwise be excluded due to scheduling can participate: those who have another job, those who live in another city or country, and those who have family responsibilities.
- More collaborative decisions. Several people on the team can review the same answers and evaluate them from different perspectives.
- Improved employer image. Respecting candidates' time counts in their experience during the selection process.
When is it appropriate to use them?
Each company can integrate them as it sees fit, but always as one more piece of the process, alongside other tests. The most common uses are:
| Situation | Why it fits |
|---|---|
| Initial phases, right after reviewing the CV | It allows for continued screening quickly and using common criteria. |
| Processes with a high volume of applications | It speeds up the process and prevents it from dragging on for weeks. |
| Junior or internship profiles | A CV says little; the answers show skills and potential. |
| Applications in different time zones | Coordinating schedules live can be impossible |
| Positions where oral communication is key | Customer service, sales, or training, for example |
Where it fits worst: in management or highly specialized positions, where live conversation and follow-up questions provide more than a recorded response.
How to design an asynchronous video interview step by step?
The design is as important as the tool itself. The doctoral thesis of Koralie Orji at the University of Neuchâtel (2025) He summarizes it like this: the video interview is not a neutral medium, and decisions such as response time or preparation change how people respond and how they are evaluated. These are the steps:
- Part of the job responsibilities. Choose the few competencies that matter most and write behavioral or situational questions for each one. If you are working with a model of competency interview, You can reuse their questions: «How did you manage a conflict in your last job?», «What criteria do you use to prioritize tasks?», or «What did you learn from the last mistake you made at work?».
- Limit the number of questions. More questions do not necessarily mean more useful information. The research reviewed in that thesis associates more preparation time and the option to re-record with better reactions from candidates, and a higher number of questions with more negative reactions.
- Set reasonable timeframes. In one of the studies for that thesis, with time limits of one, three, and five minutes per response, performance was highest with three minutes. A very short limit is overwhelming; a very long one encourages taking longer, and responses following the closing signal worsened the evaluation.
- Write clear and friendly instructions. The person will be alone in front of the camera and probably nervous. Explain how long it lasts, if they can repeat answers, and what happens afterward. A warm welcome message helps them feel at ease.
- Define the rating before watching the videos. For each question, describe what constitutes a weak, adequate, and strong response based on the competency. This promotes objectivity and reduces unconscious bias.
- Check the accessibility. Verify that the platform works with screen readers and keyboards, and offer a reasonable alternative to those who need it.
How to evaluate the responses?
The structure is what gives value to this format. The meta-analysis of Sackett, Zhang, Berry and Lievens (2022) The study places the validity of the structured interview at 0.42, compared to 0.19 for the unstructured interview. A video interview with common questions and written criteria approaches the former; a cursory review of the videos falls short of the latter.
Some guidelines for a good evaluation:
- Evaluate the content of the response (situation, action, result), not the background, lighting, or emphasis.
- Use the same scale for everyone and, if possible, have at least two evaluators score separately before commenting.
- Combine the result with other sources, such as competency tests or technical tests, depending on what the position requires.
AI can help organize responses. At Hirint, for example, the AI-powered STAR Video Interview test (15 minutes) assesses up to three competencies with three questions each and highlights the behavioral evidence that justifies the assigned level. This evidence helps in the decision-making process, but the final decision must be made by a member of the selection team. To prepare good questions, you can start with this. competency-based interview question bank.
What legal and ethical precautions should be taken?
A video interview records a person's image and voice, so it should be handled with care:
- Information and purpose. Explain why the video is being recorded, who will see it, and how long it will be kept. General Data Protection Regulation It requires that the data be only what is necessary for the purpose («data minimization») and that it not be kept longer than necessary («storage limitation»).
- Human decision. The GDPR recognizes the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing that significantly affects the individual (Art. 22). If AI is used, a human must review and decide.
- No reading emotions. The European AI regulation It prohibits AI systems that infer a person's emotions in the workplace, except for medical or security reasons (Art. 5.1.f), and considers those used to assess candidates to be high-risk (Annex III, point 4.a). It is wary of any tool that promises to deduce sincerity, personality, or mood from gestures or tone of voice.
Always apply the relevant labor and data protection regulations and, if you have specific questions, consult with legal advice.
How to explain the video interview to candidates?
For many people, this will be their first asynchronous video interview, and they will react worse if they don't understand it. In the review of the Orji's thesis, Those who conduct these interviews often describe them as less personal and less fair than a face-to-face interview, and an empathetic message improves their satisfaction. The key is a transparent, informative, and human message, whether sent by email or included in the process description. For example:
- «We want to get to know you better, beyond your CV. That's why we invite you to answer a few short questions on video, whenever you want. It's not a live interview, but a flexible way for us to listen to you carefully.».
- «The video interview is not exclusive or definitive. It will help us get to know you better and, if everything goes well, it will be followed by a personal interview.».
- «You can record from your mobile phone or computer. You just need an internet connection and a quiet space.».
Asynchronous video interviews are not a fad: they respond to a real need for agility, fairness and comparability in the selection process, provided they are designed with sound judgment and combined with live interviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long should an asynchronous video interview last?
Just enough to cover the key competencies without tiring the students. Performance suffers when there are too many questions, and in a study with time limits of one, three, and five minutes per answer, performance was better with three questions. As a practical guideline, ask a few well-chosen questions, allow a few seconds to prepare each one, and set a moderate time limit. Indicate the total duration in the invitation.
Do asynchronous video interviews replace in-person interviews?
No. They function as a preliminary stage: they help standardize the initial assessment and reserve the live interview for those who need more in-depth information. The final decision is made by a person, taking into account the job context, the results of other tests, and, usually, a live conversation.
What questions should be asked?
Behavioral or situational questions related to the job's competencies, for example: «Tell us about a time you resolved a conflict with a client.» Avoid trick questions, questions that are too technical for an initial screening, and any questions about personal information unrelated to the job. Each question should be scored using clear criteria.
Does the candidate need to install an application?
It depends on the tool. Web-based solutions usually allow you to record directly from your computer or mobile browser, without downloading anything. It's a good idea to mention this in the invitation, along with the minimum technical requirements (camera, microphone, and internet connection), and offer an alternative for anyone having trouble recording.
Can an answer be repeated?
The company decides this when setting up the interview. Allowing candidates to repeat the recording is associated with better reactions from candidates and reduces the pressure of the format. If allowed, it's advisable to limit the number of attempts and apply the same rule to everyone, so that the comparison remains fair.
If you want to see how to fit video interviews into your selection process alongside other tests, you can learn how they work at Hirint and request a demo.