Competency-based interview questions ask candidates for a real-life example from their past that relates to a job competency: "Tell me about a time when...". They work best when everyone answers the same questions, and each response is scored using the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, and Result) and a common scale. Below you'll find a bank of competency-based questions and a guide for scoring them.
Table of Contents
What are competency-based interview questions?
These are open-ended questions that seek to understand behaviors, not opinions. Instead of "Are you good at teamwork?", a specific example is requested: what happened, what the person did, and what the result was. The underlying idea is that how someone handled similar situations is a good indicator of how they will perform in the role.
Each question focuses on a specific job competency, that is, the combination of knowledge (knowing), skills (knowing how), interpersonal skills (being present), and attitude (wanting to do) that a person uses to perform their job well. If you'd like to learn more about this concept, we explain it in our article on job skills and their types.
The U.S. government's Office of Personnel Management (OPM) describes the structured interview as a method that measures job competencies by systematically asking about the candidate's behavior in past experiences and hypothetical situations, using the same questions and the same scale for everyone (OPM guideThe questions in this article are of the first type, behavioral questions. We explain how to conduct the complete interview, step by step, in [link/reference]. How to structure a competency-based interview.
What skills should be assessed in the interview?
The ones the job requires, not a universal list. Before writing a single question, define the profile of the ideal candidate and choose between four and six competencies that will make a difference in performance. competency matrix It helps to sort them by level and by role.
These are some of the most explored topics in a competency-based interview, grouped by type:
| Guy | What it analyzes | Usual skills |
|---|---|---|
| Individuals | How the person works on their own | Ease of learning, resilience, integrity, commitment |
| Leadership | How to guide others and decide | Leadership, decision-making, strategic thinking, project management |
| Motivational | What motivates her and how does she pursue her goals? | Initiative, results-oriented, contribution to company objectives |
| Analytics | How does he/she think when faced with a problem? | Problem-solving, analytical skills, creativity |
| Interpersonal | How it relates and collaborates | Teamwork, communication, conflict resolution, customer focus |
The interview also serves to identify strengths—the skills that make the person suitable for the position—and areas for development—those that could hinder their work. Both strengths and weaknesses are interpreted in relation to the position: a weakness for one role may be irrelevant for another, and many can be addressed with training before a candidate is deemed unsuitable.
Question bank: interpersonal and leadership skills
Each row includes a behavioral question and what to listen for in the response. Use one or two per competency and prepare follow-up questions to complete the narrative.
| Competence | Ask | What to look for in the answer |
|---|---|---|
| Teamwork | Describe an achievement you accomplished thanks to the effort of a team. What was your contribution? | Their specific role within the group, not just the collective result |
| Communication | Tell me about a time when you had to explain something complex to someone without technical knowledge. | How he adapted the message and how he verified that it was understood |
| Leadership | What is the biggest responsibility you have been given? How did you handle it and what results did you achieve? | Own decisions, team management, and verifiable results |
| Decision-making | Tell me about an important decision you had to make without having all the information. | How did you assess risks, who did you consult, and what would you do differently? |
| Conflict resolution | Tell me about a major disagreement you had with a colleague. What happened and how did you resolve it? | Listening, seeking agreements, and subsequent relationship |
| Customer Orientation | Tell me about a difficult client and how you handled the situation. | Empathy, concrete solution and follow-up |
Question bank: individual and analytical skills
These questions explore how the person works on their own: how they think, how they organize themselves, and how they respond to pressure.
| Competence | Ask | What to look for in the answer |
|---|---|---|
| Problem resolution | Describe a difficult moment when you changed your approach to solving a problem. | Analysis of the cause, alternatives considered, and action taken |
| Adaptability | Tell me about a time a project took an unexpected turn. How did you adapt? | Speed in reorganizing and attitude towards change |
| Results-oriented | What has been your greatest professional achievement and why do you consider it the most important? | Clear objective, personal effort, and measurable results |
| Initiative | Describe an occasion when you introduced an improvement to your work without anyone asking you to. | What did he detect, how did he propose it, and what changed? |
| Resilience | Tell me about a moment of crisis or criticism towards your work and how you overcame it. | How did she manage the emotion, what did she learn, and what changed afterward? |
| Organization | Describe a week in which you had several deadlines at once. How did you manage? | Prioritization criteria, tools, and meeting deadlines |
What questions should you ask depending on the type of position?
The weight given to each skill varies depending on the role, so the bank adapts to each vacancy. Here are some examples to get you started:
- Sales: «"Tell me about a sale that was almost lost and how you recovered it." "Describe a customer objection that was difficult to resolve.".
- Customer service: «"Tell me about a customer who arrived very upset. What did you do in the first few minutes?".
- Operations: «"Describe an error in a process that you detected before it caused a bigger problem.".
- Command posts: «"Tell me about a time when you had to give difficult feedback to a colleague.".
- Technical roles: «"Explain a technical problem you solved without having the solution documented. How did you approach it?".
How to formulate good competency-based questions?
A good competency-based question meets four conditions:
- He asks for a fact from the past. Start with "Tell me about a time when…", "Describe a situation…" or "Tell me about a time when…".
- Focus on a single competition. If you mix leadership and negotiation in the same question, you won't know what you're scoring.
- It does not suggest the answer. «"You know how to work under pressure, right?" only accepts a yes.
- It's done the same for everyone. Same text and same order, so that we can compare.
Combine these questions with the conventional ones about education and experience: some describe the person's career path, others show how they work. Prepare follow-up questions as well. OPM structured interview guide It is recommended to decide them beforehand, avoid those that give the answer, and use them to complete the missing information.
How to evaluate responses using the STAR method?
The STAR method organizes the narrative into four parts. This is how the Minnesota Department of Transportation summarizes it in its competency-based interview guide, which also asks the candidate to speak in the first person to clarify their role:
- Situation: The context. Where was he/she and what was happening?
- Task: The objective. What did I have to achieve?
- Action: what he did exactly.
- Result: how it ended and what changed.
If a part is missing, ask about it: "And what exactly did you do?", "How did it end?". Then compare the answer with the scale you defined before the interview. The OPM indicates that the scale usually has between 3 and 7 levels, the same for all competencies, with examples of behavior at each level. A simple four-level version:
| Level | What is observed |
|---|---|
| 1. No evidence | It does not provide a real example or speaks in hypotheticals ("I would do...") |
| 2. Partial evidence | There is an example, but its specific role or outcome is missing. |
| 3. Solid evidence | The four parts of STAR, with their own actions and clear results |
| 4. Key Evidence | The above, plus applied learning or a measurable result above expectations |
Signs of a weak response: always speaking in the plural ("we solved it") without specifying what they did, remaining in generalities ("I always try to listen"), or the result not being mentioned. This doesn't always mean a lack of competence; sometimes it indicates a lack of preparation or the question wasn't clear. Therefore, it's advisable to ask follow-up questions before assigning points.
Take notes during the interview and score each competency immediately after each answer, not at the end. If you score from memory, the overall impression will override the evidence.
How to complement the interview with psychometric tests?
The interview provides information about past behaviors recounted by the candidate; a psychometric test provides standardized data on skills, personality, or knowledge, comparable between individuals. These are distinct sources and reinforce each other: if a previous test indicates a low score in stress tolerance, the interview can dedicate a question to that topic and confirm or refine the result.
A balanced process combines CVs, tests, competency-based interviews, references, and, where applicable, a practical exercise. No single source makes the decision alone; evaluate before hiring It helps you arrive at the interview with more information. At Hirint, for example, the competency tests They are applied before the interview so that the recruiter can dedicate their time to what they need to validate.
The candidate is informed about the evaluation process and its purpose, and their data is processed in accordance with applicable data protection regulations. The final decision is made by those responsible for the process.
Frequently Asked Questions
What questions are asked in a competency-based interview?
Open-ended questions that ask for a real-life example from the past related to a job competency. For example: "Tell me about a time you solved a problem without having all the information," "Describe an improvement you implemented in your work," or "Tell me about a conflict with a colleague and how you handled it." One or two questions are chosen per competency and asked the same way to all candidates.
How to respond using the STAR method?
The candidate describes the Situation (context), the Task (objective), the Action (what they did), and the Result (how it ended). For the interviewer, STAR is a checklist: if a part is missing, they ask a follow-up question. A strong answer describes one's own actions in the first person and a concrete result, not an opinion about how one usually works.
How many questions per competency should be asked?
One or two well-chosen questions per competency are usually sufficient, along with follow-up questions. It's better to thoroughly assess four to six competencies than to superficially assess ten. If you're short on time, reduce the number of competencies rather than the depth: one complete STAR answer is worth more than three incomplete ones.
What is the difference between a behavioral question and a situational question?
Behavioral questions ask for a past event ("Tell me about a time you…"). Situational questions present a hypothetical scenario related to the position ("What would you do if…?"). Both can be part of a structured interview. Behavioral questions provide evidence of what the person has already done; situational questions are useful when the candidate has little prior work experience.
Does competency-based interviewing replace psychometric testing?
No. Interviews and tests measure in different ways and complement each other: tests provide comparable data, and interviews contrast that data with real-world examples. Used together, they reduce subjectivity, though they don't eliminate it. The CV, references, and the selection team's judgment complete the decision, which is always a human one.
If you want to see how to combine these questions with a pre-assessment of skills in your process, in Hirint We'll show you with a job at your company.