On a conscious level we know that everyone should be treated equally, and that we should all have the same opportunities. However, A series of biases operate in our unconscious which means that we are not always as objective as would be necessary when judging or evaluating others.
We have developed these biases throughout our lives. They have a lot to do with our life experience, and even with the type of society and culture in which we have grown up. That's why it's so hard to push them aside.
In the case of recruiters, letting these prejudices operate without any control can have very negative consequences for companies. Because, when selecting a candidate for a position, only objective aspects should be taken into account, not subjective issues.
Although we have pointed out that it is difficult to ignore these unconscious biases, we can work so that they have less and less influence on us. When it comes to recruiters, leaving aside these prejudices means giving a leap in quality when carrying out the work and selecting the most talented candidates.
Table of Contents
What are biases?
Are prejudices or stereotypes that we apply automatically and quickly and that affect our decisions and perceptions, without us being really aware of it. This happens because they are rooted in our past experiences, culture, the education we have received, and even in the social environment.
In a slightly more technical way, we can define them as unconscious thought patterns that are formed from our personal and cultural experiences. They are the result of a rapid and automatic mental process, and they lead us to make decisions and act involuntarily. In fact, there are cases where unconscious biases can be against a person's conscious beliefs.
For example, if we ask a recruiter if they are racist, they will probably say no. But, if we review the profile of the people the company has selected for the company in recent years, it is possible that we will not find individuals who are not of the predominant race in the country in question.
Why do biases exist? This is a difficult question to answer. It is a process that happens in the depths of our mind, and for which there is no scientific explanation. What does exist are a series of theories.
The theory of learning and experience argues that biases develop from an early age, as a result of life experiences and social interactions. So automatic associations are created between certain attributes and positive or negative characteristics.
For its part, the social cognition theory maintains that unconscious biases are the result of the human need to categorize and simplify the world around us. They are a kind of mental “shortcuts” to process the large amount of information to which we are exposed day after day.
Why are they important in talent acquisition?
Understanding what unconscious biases are and how they act is essential to see how they can impact when promoting diversity, equity and inclusion in companies.
Influence on hiring decisions
They can lead to discarding a candidate just for meeting certain characteristics, and preferring another whose profile is more similar to that of the recruiter himself, although may not be a good fit for the skills required for the position.
Impact on talent diversity
If recruiters are very affected by their biases, achieving diversity within the organization is going to be very complicated. Because they will show a clear tendency to Always choose the same candidate profile.
Perpetuation of inequality
When companies focus on always hiring the same type of personal and professional profile, they are undermining development opportunities of all those who do not fit the stereotype that is being applied. This perpetuates situations of inequality for certain groups.
Effects on the organizational climate
When it is perceived that there is a lack of equity in the company, and that growth opportunities are limited to certain groups of people, the Employee morale is affected. Consequently, the level of satisfaction and the company's ability to retain talent also decreases.
Improving organizational performance
If allowing biases to act has negative consequences, containing them can have a very beneficial impact on companies and their workforces.
An entity that advocates for diversity and inclusion is perceived as a good place to work. Therefore, it will be a little easier than other companies to attract and retain talent.
Furthermore, a more diverse workforce is more creative and innovative, and the environment within it is usually healthy and positive.
On the other hand, by eliminating biases in recruitment, a more objective evaluation of the candidates is made, based on their competencies. This can lead to a more accurate and efficient selection, reducing costs associated with personnel selection.
What are the most common biases among recruiters?
Here is a list of the most frequent ones:
affinity bias
Operates when the recruiter prefers candidates with whom you share certain characteristics. These can be age, gender, social origin, personal interests, etc.
The recruiter feels more comfortable with these types of people, and is likely to focus on them when making a decision.
Confirmation bias
It is the tendency of recruiters to encourage the search for information that confirms expectations that they have regarding a candidate.
For example, if the recruiter believes that a person with a specific work experience may be more competent for a position, he or she will selectively evaluate the information. Giving more importance to this fact than to other data that appears in the resume or is revealed during the personal interview.
Contrast bias
occurs when candidates are compared to each other, instead of evaluating each one in relation to the criteria required for the position.
In this way, if several candidates with a strong profile have been interviewed and then one with a weaker profile arrives, he or she may be seen as less capable compared to the rest, even if he or she is well qualified for the position.
stereotype bias
It is one of the most common, and implies that it is attributed to people one role or another depending on certain characteristics such as your age, your gender or your physical appearance.
Halo bias
The halo/horns effect implies that a positive or negative characteristic of the candidate ends up decisively influencing the overall perception that the recruiter has on him.
Proximity bias
It is the tendency to give more weight to the information obtained during the interview than to objective data that can be derived from other sources such as the resume. So the personal interaction, which has a markedly subjective nature, is what most influences the final decision.
What to do about recruiters' biases?
The starting point is the training. Recruiters must be aware of what biases are, how they operate, and which ones are most present in each of them.
To achieve this, the company is responsible for providing regular training on this topic to all those who are involved in the recruitment process. Furthermore, those responsible for selection must be made to see that their work has a very important influence on the fulfillment of the objective of achieving diversity and inclusion in the workplace.
Another effective formula is standardize selection processes. Define clear and objective evaluation criteria, based on 100% on the competencies and skills that are essential to fill a certain position. For example, implementing structured interviews with questions that are really relevant and that focus on the technical and soft skills required.
It is also useful diversify selection teams. That within them there are people of different origins, races, age, social stratum, etc., contributes very positively to reducing the risk of individual biases coming into action.
In addition to taking measures, we must analyze the results that are being obtained with them. Therefore, it is important to periodically evaluate hiring and promotion data, in order to Identify patterns of biases that continue to be applied unconsciously.
If there is a commitment from the company and its recruiters to proactively and continuously address bias, achieving diversity and inclusion will be a much easier goal to achieve. Something that, on the other hand, will improve the opportunities for professional and personal development of all people.
By moving towards making biases have less and less weight in the selection process, a more fair and equitable work environment is achieved.