The tree test is a projective technique in which a person draws a tree, and a psychologist interprets the drawing to formulate hypotheses about their personality. It still appears in some personnel selection assessments, but its traditional interpretation lacks sufficient evidence to support a hiring decision.
If you are asked for it in a process or see it in a supplier's report, here's what it is, what the research says, and what questions to ask.
Table of Contents
What is the tree test and where does it come from?
It is also known by its German name, Baumtest. It was developed in the 1940s by the Swiss psychologist Karl Koch, and his manual has been translated into other languages. A review published in Problems of Forensic Sciences (2013) He points out, for example, that the Polish edition is an unaltered translation of the 1947 German manual, with its anachronisms and without local adaptation.
Drawing a tree is also part of the HTP (house, tree, person) technique, which requires drawing all three elements. It belongs to the same family of graphic techniques as the Wartegg test, and shares with him the challenges of interpretation.
Why do they ask you to draw a tree in a job interview?
It's a common question, and the short answer is that some evaluators use it as a quick way to form hypotheses about a candidate's personality. It doesn't assess drawing ability and there's no single "right answer.".
What you should know, from both sides:
- If you're in HR: Just because a technique is quick doesn't make it suitable for decision-making. Before including it, ask what it offers that structured interviews and norm-referenced tests don't.
- If you are a candidate: You have the right to know what the test will be used for, who will see the results, and how your data will be handled. There's nothing to "prepare.".
How is it applied and what is analyzed?
The classic application is simple: the person receives a sheet of paper and a pencil and is asked to draw a tree. The psychologist then observes general aspects of the drawing, such as its size and placement on the paper, the proportions between the crown, trunk, and roots, the line work, and any added details.
We do not reproduce here the keys to interpretation or lists of "meanings". Psychologist's Code of Ethics The Mexican Society of Psychology requests that the content, answers, or possible results of the tests not be disclosed to non-psychologists (article 27). Furthermore, these lists attribute a fixed meaning to a feature of the drawing that is not supported by research.
Recent research has changed the approach: instead of interpreting the drawing by eye, it measures variables with image recognition programs, such as area, height and width of the crown or width of the trunk.
What does the evidence say about its validity?
For HR, the question is whether the interpretation of the drawing predicts anything useful about the job. Here is the available data:
- About the classical method. The review of Stemplewska-Żakowicz and Paluchowski (2013) It concludes that there is a lack of evidence to support the validity of the method used to interpret the drawings, that the reliability of its measurements is unknown, and that the test does not meet current criteria for a reliable diagnostic tool. It also warns that using it as such could be harmful.
- About projective techniques in general. The review of Lilienfeld, Wood and Garb (2000) concludes that, with few exceptions, they have not consistently shown incremental validity over other psychometric data.
- Recent clinical studies. In a 2020 study With 43 patients with major depression, 48 people with subthreshold symptoms, and 59 controls, five computer-measured variables differentiated the groups. Between depression and subthreshold symptoms, only one variable, cup width, showed differences. another study from 2025 With 104 adolescents, a computerized scale to detect depression achieved a sensitivity of 0.780 and a specificity of 0.981, and its authors present it as a preliminary tool, with a small sample and without considering cultural differences.
The table summarizes what can and cannot be stated:
| Common statement | What the evidence says | Implication for selection |
|---|---|---|
| «"Each feature of the drawing reveals a personality trait"» | There is a lack of evidence to support the validity of the classical interpretation. | Do not base conclusions on lists of meanings |
| «"Two psychologists arrive at the same interpretation"» | The reliability of the classical method is unknown. | Request the system used and who interpreted it. |
| «"It helps detect depression"» | There are preliminary clinical studies, with computerized measurement. | It is not a selection question and it does not fall under HR. |
| «"Predicts job performance"» | There are no known studies that show this. | Use methods with evidence on performance |
Can it be used for personnel selection in Mexico?
It's not prohibited, but there are three limits that HR must be clear about.
1. Who applies and interprets it. The Code of Ethics of the Mexican Society of Psychology includes personnel selection among the purposes of psychological assessment (Article 15) and requires that techniques be based on solid data regarding reliability, validity, and norms (Article 17), that instruments not be used that are merely translated or based on data from other populations (Article 18), and that they not be used by untrained individuals (Article 21). If the material is a translation without studies involving Mexican populations, it is difficult to comply with Article 18.
2. Health is not a hiring criterion. The Federal Labor Law It prohibits employers from refusing to hire workers based on their health conditions, among other reasons (Article 133, Section I). If a report infers an emotional state or a possible disorder from a drawing, that information should not be considered in the decision.
3. Sensitive personal data. Health status is among the sensitive data of the Federal Law on the Protection of Personal Data Held by Private Parties, which requires their express written consent (Article 8). Check with your legal department what data the company receives from the supplier: this is not legal advice.
If you already receive reports with tree analysis tests, these questions will help you read them:
- Which psychologist applied and interpreted it, and what training did they have in the technique?
- What interpretation system was used and with what rules?
- Which job behavior is related to each finding?
- Does another independent source support the same conclusion?
- Does the report include health data that the company doesn't need?
Which alternatives have more evidence?
If the goal is to anticipate how a person will work, it's best to rely on methods with direct evidence of performance: a structured interview with an evaluation guide, cognitive ability tests, personality questionnaires with norms, and job knowledge tests. Our guide to psychological work test explains how to organize that evaluation, and the evaluation of psychometric tests for work how to choose each type.
When you need comparable results across candidates, Hirint offers Psychometric and technical tests for MexicoCognitive, personality, DISC, soft skills, languages and knowledge, which complement the CV and the interview.
When might the tree drawing test be appropriate? At most, in the hands of a trained psychologist who uses it as one more source of hypotheses, in processes with few candidates and time to test them. Never to eliminate someone on their own or in large-scale recruitment processes. The final decision is human and must be justifiable in relation to the job requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the tree test diagnose a disease?
No. The 2013 review of the classic method concludes that it does not meet current criteria for a reliable diagnostic tool. There are recent clinical studies using computer-measured scales for adolescent depression screening, but their authors consider them preliminary. A diagnosis is made by a healthcare professional through a comprehensive evaluation, never based on a drawing.
Can the tree test be used in personnel selection?
It can be used as a source of hypotheses, applied and interpreted by a psychologist, but not as a criterion for hiring or rejecting candidates. No studies have shown that it predicts job performance. Furthermore, in Mexico, a candidate cannot be rejected based on their health conditions, and the disclosure of health data requires explicit written consent.
What does it mean to draw a house, a tree, and a person?
This is the HTP, a projective technique that asks the subject to draw these three elements in order to formulate hypotheses about their personality. It shares the limitations of the Tree Test: the interpretation depends heavily on the evaluator, and its validity is not well established. In selection, the same precautions apply to the three drawings.
How do you interpret a drawn tree?
It's interpreted by a psychologist trained in the technique, based on aspects such as size, location, and proportions, and always as a hypothesis. Online lists that assign a fixed meaning to every detail lack empirical support. If you receive a report, ask for an explanation of the basis for each conclusion and what other source confirms it.
How can I prepare if they ask me to take the tree drawing test in an interview?
There are no right or wrong answers, nor is there a single "correct" way to draw the tree diagram, so memorizing tips is pointless. What's helpful is asking what purpose it's intended for, who will interpret it, and how your data will be protected. A thorough assessment combines various tests and an interview, and doesn't rely on a single diagram.
Do you want your assessment to be supported by evidence that you can explain to each candidate? At Hirint, we can review it with you.