In recent times there has been a lot of talk about how important it is to have a healthy and positive work environment in which everyone feels integrated, but we tend to forget that this is the opposite of what has been called a toxic work culture.
The one in which the lack of communication, abusive behavior, lack of recognition and mistrust have undermined the motivation of the staff and generated a work environment in which no one feels comfortable.
Although toxic cultures may seem like a thing of the past, unfortunately they are not yet and, therefore, we want to do a more in-depth analysis of what they are and what they imply.
Table of Contents
What is a toxic work culture?
This is how we define work environments in which there is a clear predominance of negative behaviors and attitudes, a phenomenon that adversely affects employees and the organization as a whole.
Although each toxic culture can be different, we find in them a series of common traits that it is important to know how to identify:
- Lack of effective communication. Information does not flow vertically or horizontally, this causes the appearance of rumors and enhances the lack of transparency in the decision-making process.
- Distrust and hostility. Precisely because communication is not good, there is an atmosphere of hostility between coworkers and between them and management that is the result of mistrust.
- Lack of recognition. The achievements and efforts carried out by staff members are not recognized or rewarded in any way.
- Abusive behaviors. It is common for such reprehensible behavior as harassment, intimidation, discrimination or unfair treatment to occur.
- Lack of support and resources. Workers do not have the tools, resources or support they need at their disposal to perform their tasks effectively.
- Excessive workload. The lack of resources, mistrust and competition between colleagues generate an excessive workload that is difficult to cope with.
On the other hand, we have a positive culture, which is one in which positive behaviors and attitudes predominate, which increases employee motivation and increases productivity levels.
Let's see a small comparison between both types of cultures:
| Toxic Culture | Positive Culture | |
| Inclusion | People feel discriminated against due to factors such as their age, their ethnic origin, their gender, their sexual orientation, etc. They have perceived that they are offered fewer professional development opportunities than colleagues who fit other profiles. | Everyone feels valued and employees know they have the same career development opportunities as their peers. |
| Chores and Companionship | Employees have to do a lot of work in a short time and with hardly any resources. Fierce competition between colleagues is common, because it is the only way to stand out. | Managers understand the importance of work-life balance and the distribution of tasks between employees is equitable. There is a strong feeling of camaraderie among staff members, because everyone will have the opportunity to have their work valued and rewarded. |
| Stake | People are reluctant to share their ideas and opinions because they fear the consequences. | Employees are enthusiastic about the idea of being able to present their ideas and provide suggestions that improve the company's performance. |
We can find many real examples of toxic work cultures, but we highlight for its relevance the case of Volkswagen and Dieselgate, which shows us how this type of culture that we are analyzing can trigger dishonest practices and have serious consequences for a company.
Volkswagen employees were under a lot of pressure to meet their performance goals, which may have led some of them to make the decision to falsify CO2 emissions tests in order to meet their goals. Something that was not very difficult, since the hierarchical structure of the company had centralized power in the hands of a few executives, who were the ones who made unethical decisions.
The manipulation of emissions tests took place for several years without anyone knowing, which is a symptom of a clear lack of transparency within the company. And those who knew did not want to report it for fear of reprisals.
In the end, the scandal came to light and the automotive company had to pay penalties worth more than $30 billion and face the even greater cost of going through a major reputation crisis and loss of consumer trust.
The future of people and organizations are Skills.
Will you join us?
Factors that generate a toxic work culture
There is never a single reason why a company's culture is toxic, rather it is a combination of factors such as the following:
Ineffective leadership
If the person who must exercise leadership is not qualified for it and what he ends up doing is exercising a excessive control over employeesIn the end they become totally demotivated.
Furthermore, as in the case of Volkswagen, the leader who really does not know how to be one may be tempted to fall into dishonest practices to hide his inability.
Poor communication
The communication is essential to generate an environment of trust and ensure that messages are being transmitted and received correctly within the entire chain of command. When this does not happen, the rumors and mistrust.
Inadequate Human Resources Policies
If there is no system of recognition of effort and rewards, or if performance evaluation practices are neither fair nor transparent, in the end discouragement spreads among the workforce, because employees are aware that They do not have any opportunity for development and professional growth within the organization.
Excessive pressure and stress
Excessive demands regarding the objectives to be achieved, the lack of training and training, and the lack of balance between personal and professional life, alter the state of mind and are a source of stress and anxiety. This ends up causing an unhealthy work environment.
Lack of diversity and inclusion
If the company does not value or respect differences, certain groups of people end up being excluded, sometimes consciously and other times unconsciously (through biases).
Consequences for people and organizations
The study "Perceived unfairness and employee health” by Jordan M. Robbins, Michael T. Ford and Lois E. Tetrick revealed, back in 2011, that the Feelings of injustice can negatively affect employee health. Many years have passed since then, but this has not changed and, today, we know that working in a toxic environment is directly associated with high levels of stress, exhaustion and mental health problems. Continued exposure to this toxicity can even lead to physical illnesses.
The suffering that this type of culture entails for workers is incalculable, but the impact it has on the organization can be calculated. Because other quantifiable phenomena are derived from this phenomenon, such as:
- Increase in absenteeism and staff turnover.
- Lower productivity.
How to protect yourself from a toxic culture
All part of one good communication, as a basis for knowing how employees feel, what they need to do their job better and what career aspirations they have. From there, you can begin to take measures to make the work culture as positive as possible.
As a starting point we should:
- Know what each person needs to enhance their creativity.
- Know the fears and insecurities of team members.
- Detect the first signs of toxic behavior.
- Make a good fit between people's capabilities and competencies and the role they occupy in the company.
- Give fair recognition to those who make efforts.
How can it be avoided through a good evaluation and
Talent management
Incorporating new employees into the company is a critical point in the fight against toxic culture. If we do not want people who do not fit well with the corporate culture to enter the workforce, we must apply a series of principles that help us consistently and sustainably improve the selection. Guidelines that will help us anticipate future problems, beyond solving current ones.
To achieve this, we can take measures like these:
- Align the selection of people with the organizational culture and values.
- Identify the ideal characteristics that people should have for a proper fit in the organization.
- Take into account the characteristics of the team that each person is going to join.
- Conduct systematic and periodic evaluations, for both external and internal talent, to align objectives and expectations with capabilities. [Here] you can see our test catalog.
- Boost people's talent through personalized learning programs for different skills.
- Promote a healthy environment in which leaders are an example.