To assess soft skills, first define the behaviors required by the position and measure them using structured instruments: behavioral interviews, psychometric tests, situational exercises, 360-degree feedback, and references. No single method is sufficient on its own; it is recommended to combine at least two, apply the same rubric to all candidates, and compare the results with the job requirements.
Table of Contents
Why assess the soft skills of your employees?
Technology allows us to copy ways of working: if one company automates its accounting with software, its competitor can buy the same software. Human talent, however, cannot be copied. As machines take over repetitive tasks, the work that remains demands more communication, judgment, collaboration, and adaptability.
For a long time, organizations measured performance only in quantitative terms: pieces per day, monthly workload. These metrics are still useful, but they don't show how a person works with others or how they respond when circumstances change. soft skills They don't just talk about what someone is doing today, but about what they can achieve.
Evaluating them is useful at two points: in the selection process, to compare candidates with the job profile, and in the development process, to determine where to invest in training. In both cases, measurement only makes sense if the result informs a decision or a plan.
What should a good soft skills assessment include?
Previously, it was difficult to measure these abilities, and the analyses tended to be quite subjective. Today, structured instruments exist, but not all are equally effective. A good assessment meets five conditions:
- Precision. It provides detailed and realistic information about specific behaviors, such as communication or teamwork, not a general impression.
- Objectivity. Everyone goes through the same process, using the same criteria, so that factors unrelated to the position have as little influence as possible. Standardized tools and structured questionnaires help reduce bias.
- Efficiency. It doesn't take up too much time for either the person responding or the person analyzing. Technology speeds up the application and correction process.
- Reliability and validity. The instrument measures consistently and measures what it claims to measure. Ask the provider for information about how it was constructed, its reliability, validity, and the reference population.
- Control of social desirability. In self-perception questionnaires, individuals may attempt to present a favorable image. Psychometric design, consistency indicators, and cross-referencing with other sources reduce this risk.
Preliminary step: define which skills and behaviors to evaluate
You can't accurately measure what hasn't been defined. To set priorities, you need to understand the company culture, its strategic objectives, and the requirements of each position; that's why human resources needs to work with the leaders of each area.
- Part of the position. Review the tasks, objectives, and challenging situations of the role. Databases such as O*NET, from the U.S. Department of Labor, describe the work styles that influence performance, such as reliability, self-control, or stress tolerance, and serve as inspiration.
- Choose a few. Between four and six skills that make a difference in that position.
- Translate them into observable behaviors. «"Communication" can be specified as "clearly explaining a technical problem to a client" or "summarizing agreements at the end of a meeting.".
- Set the expected level. What is considered sufficient and what is considered outstanding for that role.
What methods are used to assess soft skills?
These are the most commonly used methods, along with the benefits of each:
| Method | What measures best | Main advantage | Main boundary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Behavioral interview | Past behaviors in real situations | It goes deeper and allows for follow-up questions | It depends on the interviewer's preparation |
| Psychometric tests and soft skills tests | Comparable behavioral trends between people | Standardized and applicable to many people | Self-perception: requires social desirability control |
| Situational exercises (SJT) | Judgment in job situations | Easy to apply online | They measure what the person would choose, not what they do |
| Assessment center and simulations | Behavior observed in job exercises | Lots of information about various competitions | Expensive and slow to prepare |
| 360 Evaluation | Daily behavior as seen by several people | Combine perspectives | This only applies to people who already work at the company. |
| Structured references | Previous performance | Contrast what the candidate stated | Some candidates may perceive them as invasive. |
Behavioral interview
Ask for real-life examples from the past related to each skill ("Tell me about a time when…") and assess the response using the STAR method: situation, task, action, and result. You have a question bank for each competency at [link/website address]. How to assess skills in an interview. It works better when structured: same questions, same order, and same scale for everyone.
Psychometric tests and soft skills tests
Standardized questionnaires allow for comparison of results between individuals and against a job profile. They are the most efficient way to evaluate many people using the same criteria, provided the instrument is validated and supported by evidence. soft skills test It can be applied before the interview to find out which skills to develop further.
What do situational exercises, assessment centers, 360-degree feedback, and references contribute?
Interviews and tests cover most processes. These four methods add information when the position warrants it.
Situational exercises
Situational judgment tests present a job problem or critical situation and ask respondents to choose how they would handle it. The U.S. government's Office of Personnel Management (OPM) explains that they measure dimensions such as conflict management, interpersonal skills, problem-solving, and negotiation, and are especially useful for assessing command and leadership competencies.OPM, situational judgment tests).
Assessment center and simulations
It is not a place, but a process that combines various exercises, often simulations of real work, to observe several competencies simultaneously: interpersonal skills, oral and written communication, planning, and problem-solving. According to the OPM, They predict occupational success well, although they contribute less to individual development feedback.
360 Evaluation
It gathers the perspectives of the boss, colleagues, collaborators, and sometimes clients on behaviors observed on a daily basis. It's very useful for development and for identifying differences between how a person sees themselves and how others see them. We'll tell you how to apply it in 360-degree evaluation.
Structured references
References provide information about past performance and help to corroborate what the candidate says in other phases. They work best with structured questions, just like the interview.OPM, reference checking).
How to combine the methods?
There is no single best method: the best approach is to combine at least two and compare the results. Two common combinations:
- In selection: soft skills test before the interview, behavioral interview focused on what the test left in doubt and, for key positions, a situational exercise or a structured reference.
- Under development: soft skills test plus 360 assessment, followed by a feedback conversation and an individual plan.
When sources don't agree, don't choose the one that seems most convincing: look for the explanation. A high test score and poor interview examples can indicate social desirability bias, lack of experience, or a poorly worded question. At Hirint, for example, soft skills tests are combined with video interviews and 360-degree feedback to cross-reference information about the same person. Ultimately, the decision rests with the people involved.
What to do with the results?
Measurement is of little use if the information is not then utilized. The goal is to build a talent development strategy.
- Feedback. Each person should learn their results in a constructive conversation, not just in a report.
- Tailor-made development programs. Coaching, workshops or mentoring focused on one or two specific skills per person.
- Learning culture. Employees participate more effectively when they understand the purpose of the evaluation and how it can help them. grow professionally. Explaining it also influences its work motivation.
- Program review. Measure again after a while and adjust what isn't working.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are soft skills measured objectively?
With structured instruments and the same criteria for everyone. Define the behaviors you are looking for beforehand, use a common rubric with examples for each level, and combine at least two sources, for example, a soft skills test and a behavioral interview. Total objectivity is impossible, but structure greatly reduces the influence of personal impressions.
What tool is used to assess soft skills?
It depends on the objective. To compare many candidates, a validated soft skills test is the most efficient. For in-depth analysis, a behavioral interview using the STAR method is recommended. For current employees, 360-degree feedback provides the perspective of those who work with the person. It's advisable to combine several methods and always compare them against the job profile.
Can soft skills be assessed online?
Yes. Digital assessments allow for the application of standardized instruments to candidates or employees regardless of their location, and also include video interviews where the person answers pre-configured questions. The important thing is that the instrument is validated and that the experience is clear and appropriate for the position.
Does a soft skills test replace the interview?
No. The test provides comparable data, and the interview contrasts it with real-world examples from the candidate's experience. They work best together: the test indicates which skills to develop further, and the interview confirms or refines the results. Neither replaces the CV or the selection team's judgment, as they are the ones who make the final decision.
How often should employees' soft skills be assessed?
There's no universal frequency. Many companies do it at the start of a development plan and measure again at the end, or they align it with their performance review cycle. The important thing is to allow enough time for the change to become visible and to use the same tool for comparison.
If you want to see how to assess the soft skills of your candidates and employees with comparable results, in Hirint We'll show it to you.